See Transcript
Episode 21, 9/18/2026
Corresponding blog: Is the Northern Michigan Housing Market Finally Shifting Toward Buyers?
Episode Summary
The Northern Michigan housing market is showing signs of becoming more balanced in 2026, with buyers generally seeing more choices, longer decision windows, and greater negotiating room than during the pandemic-era market. But Northern Michigan is not one uniform housing market, and conditions can differ significantly by county, price range, property type, and location.
Full Transcript
Introduction
[00:10]
Welcome to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence. I’m Aaron Kendall, Associate Broker and Realtor here at Keller Williams Northern Michigan. Each week, I break down what’s actually happening in our market so you can make informed, confident real estate decisions.
This week, I want to revisit a question that I think is becoming increasingly important as we move through September 2026.
Is the Northern Michigan housing market finally shifting toward buyers?
But there’s a second part to that question that may be even more important.
When we say “the Northern Michigan market,” are Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Antrim, Kalkaska, Wexford and Missaukee counties actually moving in the same direction?
Because if they aren’t, talking about Northern Michigan as one market can be misleading.
[00:57]
The Core Topic
[00:59]
Let’s start with the bigger picture.
Compared with the extremely competitive market buyers experienced during 2021 and 2022, conditions have changed.
Buyers generally have more breathing room. Inventory has increased in many areas. Homes that are overpriced are most definitely sitting longer. Price reductions have become more noticeable and frequent, and buyers are often taking more time before making a decision.
That certainly sounds like a market moving toward buyers.
But there’s an important distinction between moving toward buyers and actually being a buyer’s market.
Those aren’t necessarily the same thing.
[01:38]
A true buyer’s market generally exists when the supply of homes exceeds buyer demand enough that buyers consistently have the stronger negotiating position. Typically that is when there is at least 6 months’ worth of inventory.
I don’t think it’s accurate to make that blanket statement about Northern Michigan.
What I think we’re seeing instead is a gradual movement away from the extreme seller-controlled conditions of several years ago and toward something more balanced.
And frankly, balance isn’t necessarily bad for either side.
Buyers don’t feel like they have to make a decision five minutes after walking through the door.
They may have an opportunity to negotiate.
They can look more carefully at inspections, financing and the actual condition of the property.
But sellers can still sell successfully. They just can’t necessarily assume that putting a house on the market means buyers will compete for it regardless of price or condition.
And that’s where the second part of today’s question becomes important.
[02:36]
Market Explanation
[02:37]
Northern Michigan is not one housing market.
It is a collection of smaller markets that sometimes behave very differently from one another.
Grand Traverse County isn’t necessarily behaving like Wexford County.
Leelanau County isn’t necessarily behaving like Kalkaska County.
And even within a single county, a waterfront property can behave very differently from a conventional home ten miles away.
That’s why broad headlines about whether we’re in a buyer’s market or seller’s market don’t tell you nearly enough.
Take Traverse City and Grand Traverse County.
Demand remains significant, but buyers have become more selective. They’re comparing properties more carefully, watching monthly payments and looking harder at whether the asking price is justified. Homes that are well positioned and properly priced can still attract strong interest, while overpriced or dated homes may sit considerably longer.
Now compare that with Cadillac and Wexford County.
Housing there is generally more affordable, which creates a different buyer pool. But those buyers can also be particularly sensitive to interest rates and monthly payments. When inventory increases, the additional choices can become more noticeable because buyers have alternatives they didn’t have during the tightest years.
[03:55]
Then you have places like Leelanau, Benzie and Antrim counties, where the mix of properties can make countywide numbers difficult to interpret without context.
You may have primary residences, second homes, vacation properties, acreage, waterfront and luxury homes all contributing to the same set of county statistics.
And that matters.
Imagine one county has twenty additional homes come onto the market.
That might represent a meaningful increase in supply.
Now imagine another county adds twenty homes but normally carries several times as much inventory.
Same twenty houses.
Very different effect on the market.
Property type matters too.
[04:38]
Northern Michigan waterfront is a good example.
Demand for desirable waterfront property hasn’t simply disappeared because the broader market has become less frantic. But waterfront buyers are becoming more selective. They’re looking at the quality of the frontage, condition of the home, short-term rental restrictions, carrying costs and whether the property’s asking price actually makes sense.
That gives us an important clue about what is really changing.
I don’t think this is simply a story about buyers replacing sellers as the side with all the power.
It’s a story about leverage becoming more property-specific and location-specific.
[05:19]
A buyer looking at an overpriced house that’s been sitting for three months may have considerable negotiating room.
That same buyer could look at a properly priced home in a desirable neighborhood the next morning and find themselves competing with somebody else.
Both situations can exist in Northern Michigan at exactly the same time.
That’s why I would be very careful about looking at one statistic and deciding the entire market has turned.
Days on market can tell us something.
Inventory can tell us something.
Price reductions can tell us something.
Sale-to-list price can tell us something.
But none of those numbers tells the entire story by itself.
And smaller Northern Michigan counties create another challenge: relatively small changes in the number or type of transactions can sometimes move countywide statistics substantially.
So when I’m evaluating whether conditions are becoming more favorable to buyers, I want to know more about whether inventory went up.
What kind of inventory went up?
At what price?
Where is it located?
How long is it actually taking those homes to sell?
Are sellers reducing prices?
Are buyers successfully negotiating concessions?
And most importantly, does any of that apply to the particular type of property you’re trying to buy or sell?
That’s where the answer becomes useful.
[06:45]
For buyers, the takeaway isn’t that Northern Michigan suddenly became cheap or that you should start throwing low offers at every property.
It’s that you may have options today that buyers didn’t have several years ago.
You can sometimes take a little more time.
You may be able to negotiate.
You may be able to insist on protections that buyers were waiving during the most competitive market.
But you still have to recognize a good property when one comes along.
[07:13]
For sellers, the lesson is almost the mirror image.
There are still buyers.
There is still demand.
But today’s buyer have alternatives.
That means pricing and presentation matter more.
If three similar properties are available and yours is clearly overpriced, buyers don’t necessarily have to negotiate with you.
They can simply buy one of the other two.
And I think that’s one of the biggest changes from the market we experienced several years ago.
[07:42]
If you’d like to see the broader discussion behind today’s episode, I covered it in this week’s corresponding blog post, “Is the Northern Michigan Housing Market Finally Shifting Toward Buyers?” You can find it in the blog section at AaronKendallRealEstate.com.
The main point I want you to take away is this:
Yes, there are signs that buyers have regained some leverage in Northern Michigan.
But that does not mean every county has crossed into a buyer’s market, and it certainly doesn’t mean every property is behaving the same way.
The market is becoming more selective.
And the more selective the market becomes, the more important local data becomes.
[08:20]
Wrap Up
[08:21]
If you found this episode useful, follow or subscribe to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence wherever you listen, and check back next week for another look at the issues affecting Northern Michigan buyers, sellers and property owners.
And if you’d like to dive deeper on this, you can ask NorMI™ something like: “Compare Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Antrim, Kalkaska, Wexford, and Missaukee counties and tell me which are showing the strongest signs of shifting toward buyers based on current inventory, days on market, price reductions, and negotiating leverage.”
If you are following along on the transcript you can just click on those words and watch NorMI™ analyze your specific situation.
Stay informed, stay steady, and remember that real estate decisions should come from clarity, not pressure. I’ll talk with you next week.
[09:10]
Paragraph Block
According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, the Northern Michigan housing market is showing signs of becoming more balanced, giving some buyers more choices, more time to make decisions, and greater negotiating room than they had during the highly competitive pandemic-era market. However, conditions can vary significantly among counties, communities, price ranges, and property types, so a broad regional label does not tell the whole story.
Voice Assistant Block
Voice Assistant Answer: Northern Michigan is showing signs of shifting toward a more balanced housing market, but that does not mean every county is now a buyer’s market. Buyers generally have more choices and negotiating room than several years ago, while desirable, properly priced properties can still attract strong demand. Local conditions matter more than the regional headline.