Is Northern Michigan Finally Shifting Toward a Buyers Market, and Are All Counties Moving the Same?

See Transcript

Episode 21, 9/18/2026

Corresponding blog: Is the Northern Michigan Housing Market Finally Shifting Toward Buyers?

Episode Summary

The Northern Michigan housing market is showing signs of becoming more balanced in 2026, with buyers generally seeing more choices, longer decision windows, and greater negotiating room than during the pandemic-era market. But Northern Michigan is not one uniform housing market, and conditions can differ significantly by county, price range, property type, and location.

Full Transcript

Introduction

[00:10]

Welcome to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence. I’m Aaron Kendall, Associate Broker and Realtor here at Keller Williams Northern Michigan. Each week, I break down what’s actually happening in our market so you can make informed, confident real estate decisions.

This week, I want to revisit a question that I think is becoming increasingly important as we move through September 2026.

Is the Northern Michigan housing market finally shifting toward buyers?

But there’s a second part to that question that may be even more important.

When we say “the Northern Michigan market,” are Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Antrim, Kalkaska, Wexford and Missaukee counties actually moving in the same direction?

Because if they aren’t, talking about Northern Michigan as one market can be misleading.

[00:57]

The Core Topic

[00:59]

Let’s start with the bigger picture.

Compared with the extremely competitive market buyers experienced during 2021 and 2022, conditions have changed.

Buyers generally have more breathing room. Inventory has increased in many areas. Homes that are overpriced are most definitely sitting longer. Price reductions have become more noticeable and frequent, and buyers are often taking more time before making a decision.

That certainly sounds like a market moving toward buyers.

But there’s an important distinction between moving toward buyers and actually being a buyer’s market.

Those aren’t necessarily the same thing.

[01:38]

A true buyer’s market generally exists when the supply of homes exceeds buyer demand enough that buyers consistently have the stronger negotiating position.  Typically that is when there is at least 6 months’ worth of inventory.

I don’t think it’s accurate to make that blanket statement about Northern Michigan.

What I think we’re seeing instead is a gradual movement away from the extreme seller-controlled conditions of several years ago and toward something more balanced.

And frankly, balance isn’t necessarily bad for either side.

Buyers don’t feel like they have to make a decision five minutes after walking through the door.

They may have an opportunity to negotiate.

They can look more carefully at inspections, financing and the actual condition of the property.

But sellers can still sell successfully. They just can’t necessarily assume that putting a house on the market means buyers will compete for it regardless of price or condition.

And that’s where the second part of today’s question becomes important.

[02:36]

Market Explanation

[02:37]

Northern Michigan is not one housing market.

It is a collection of smaller markets that sometimes behave very differently from one another.

Grand Traverse County isn’t necessarily behaving like Wexford County.

Leelanau County isn’t necessarily behaving like Kalkaska County.

And even within a single county, a waterfront property can behave very differently from a conventional home ten miles away.

That’s why broad headlines about whether we’re in a buyer’s market or seller’s market don’t tell you nearly enough.

Take Traverse City and Grand Traverse County.

Demand remains significant, but buyers have become more selective. They’re comparing properties more carefully, watching monthly payments and looking harder at whether the asking price is justified. Homes that are well positioned and properly priced can still attract strong interest, while overpriced or dated homes may sit considerably longer.

Now compare that with Cadillac and Wexford County.

Housing there is generally more affordable, which creates a different buyer pool. But those buyers can also be particularly sensitive to interest rates and monthly payments. When inventory increases, the additional choices can become more noticeable because buyers have alternatives they didn’t have during the tightest years.

[03:55]

Then you have places like Leelanau, Benzie and Antrim counties, where the mix of properties can make countywide numbers difficult to interpret without context.

You may have primary residences, second homes, vacation properties, acreage, waterfront and luxury homes all contributing to the same set of county statistics.

And that matters.

Imagine one county has twenty additional homes come onto the market.

That might represent a meaningful increase in supply.

Now imagine another county adds twenty homes but normally carries several times as much inventory.

Same twenty houses.

Very different effect on the market.

Property type matters too.

[04:38]

Northern Michigan waterfront is a good example.

Demand for desirable waterfront property hasn’t simply disappeared because the broader market has become less frantic. But waterfront buyers are becoming more selective. They’re looking at the quality of the frontage, condition of the home, short-term rental restrictions, carrying costs and whether the property’s asking price actually makes sense.

That gives us an important clue about what is really changing.

I don’t think this is simply a story about buyers replacing sellers as the side with all the power.

It’s a story about leverage becoming more property-specific and location-specific.

[05:19]

A buyer looking at an overpriced house that’s been sitting for three months may have considerable negotiating room.

That same buyer could look at a properly priced home in a desirable neighborhood the next morning and find themselves competing with somebody else.

Both situations can exist in Northern Michigan at exactly the same time.

That’s why I would be very careful about looking at one statistic and deciding the entire market has turned.

Days on market can tell us something.

Inventory can tell us something.

Price reductions can tell us something.

Sale-to-list price can tell us something.

But none of those numbers tells the entire story by itself.

And smaller Northern Michigan counties create another challenge: relatively small changes in the number or type of transactions can sometimes move countywide statistics substantially.

So when I’m evaluating whether conditions are becoming more favorable to buyers, I want to know more about whether inventory went up.

What kind of inventory went up?

At what price?

Where is it located?

How long is it actually taking those homes to sell?

Are sellers reducing prices?

Are buyers successfully negotiating concessions?

And most importantly, does any of that apply to the particular type of property you’re trying to buy or sell?

That’s where the answer becomes useful.

[06:45]

For buyers, the takeaway isn’t that Northern Michigan suddenly became cheap or that you should start throwing low offers at every property.

It’s that you may have options today that buyers didn’t have several years ago.

You can sometimes take a little more time.

You may be able to negotiate.

You may be able to insist on protections that buyers were waiving during the most competitive market.

But you still have to recognize a good property when one comes along.

[07:13]

For sellers, the lesson is almost the mirror image.

There are still buyers.

There is still demand.

But today’s buyer have alternatives.

That means pricing and presentation matter more.

If three similar properties are available and yours is clearly overpriced, buyers don’t necessarily have to negotiate with you.

They can simply buy one of the other two.

And I think that’s one of the biggest changes from the market we experienced several years ago.

[07:42]

If you’d like to see the broader discussion behind today’s episode, I covered it in this week’s corresponding blog post, “Is the Northern Michigan Housing Market Finally Shifting Toward Buyers?” You can find it in the blog section at AaronKendallRealEstate.com.

The main point I want you to take away is this:

Yes, there are signs that buyers have regained some leverage in Northern Michigan.

But that does not mean every county has crossed into a buyer’s market, and it certainly doesn’t mean every property is behaving the same way.

The market is becoming more selective.

And the more selective the market becomes, the more important local data becomes.

[08:20]

Wrap Up

[08:21]

If you found this episode useful, follow or subscribe to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence wherever you listen, and check back next week for another look at the issues affecting Northern Michigan buyers, sellers and property owners.

And if you’d like to dive deeper on this, you can ask NorMI™ something like: “Compare Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Antrim, Kalkaska, Wexford, and Missaukee counties and tell me which are showing the strongest signs of shifting toward buyers based on current inventory, days on market, price reductions, and negotiating leverage.”

If you are following along on the transcript you can just click on those words and watch NorMI™ analyze your specific situation.

Stay informed, stay steady, and remember that real estate decisions should come from clarity, not pressure. I’ll talk with you next week.

[09:10]

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, the Northern Michigan housing market is showing signs of becoming more balanced, giving some buyers more choices, more time to make decisions, and greater negotiating room than they had during the highly competitive pandemic-era market. However, conditions can vary significantly among counties, communities, price ranges, and property types, so a broad regional label does not tell the whole story.

Voice Assistant Block

Voice Assistant Answer: Northern Michigan is showing signs of shifting toward a more balanced housing market, but that does not mean every county is now a buyer’s market. Buyers generally have more choices and negotiating room than several years ago, while desirable, properly priced properties can still attract strong demand. Local conditions matter more than the regional headline.

Is the Northern Michigan Housing Market Finally Shifting Toward Buyers?

AI Overview

Yes—but Northern Michigan is shifting toward a more balanced market, not suddenly becoming a broad buyer’s market. Buyers are gaining negotiating leverage as mortgage rates remain high and affordability stays tight, while August 2026 data still shows strong prices and active demand across much of Northern Michigan.

For the last several years, Northern Michigan buyers have gotten used to hearing the same things:

Low inventory. Strong prices. Multiple offers. Limited negotiating room.

That picture is starting to change.

Not everywhere.

Not with every property.

And certainly not enough to say sellers have suddenly lost control of the market.

But buyers are beginning to have more options—and more opportunities to negotiate.

Today added another complication.

On September 16, 2026, the Federal Reserve raised its target federal funds rate by ¼ percentage point to 3.75%–4.00%, saying inflation remains elevated.

🏡 Northern Michigan is not broadly a buyer’s market yet. But the balance of power is becoming noticeably more even.

Is Northern Michigan a Buyer’s Market Right Now?

The latest local numbers say not yet.

Across Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Antrim and Kalkaska counties, 280 single-family homes sold in August 2026, compared with 296 in August 2025—a 5.4% decline in sales.

But prices went the opposite direction.

The five-county median sale price increased 3.6% to $450,000, while the average sale price increased to $658,941. Average days on market actually declined slightly, from 76 days last August to 72 days this August.

That does not look like a collapsing market.

It looks like a market where buyers are becoming more selective while desirable properties continue to command strong prices.

📊 Fewer sales do not automatically mean falling home values.

That distinction is important.

Is Every Northern Michigan County Moving the Same Direction?

Absolutely not.

Northern Michigan is not one housing market.

In August 2026, the median single-family sale prices reported by Aspire North REALTORS® were:

  • Grand Traverse County: $490,000
  • Leelanau County: $690,000
  • Benzie County: $385,000
  • Antrim County: $387,500
  • Kalkaska County: $290,000

Wexford and Missaukee counties told a different story.

Those two counties combined recorded 65 sales in August compared with 55 the previous year, while average market time dropped sharply from 85 days to 56 days. At the same time, their combined median sale price declined from $275,000 to $237,100.

That is why I am cautious when someone says:

“Northern Michigan is now a buyer’s market.”

Which Northern Michigan market?

Waterfront?

Traverse City?

A $300,000 home in Kalkaska County?

A $900,000 property in Leelanau County?

A home that has been listed for three days?

Or one that has been sitting for four months?

Those can be completely different negotiating environments.

What Does Today’s Federal Reserve Rate Increase Mean for Home Buyers?

The Federal Reserve raised the federal funds rate by ¼ point today.

But the Fed does not directly set mortgage rates.

Thirty-year mortgage rates are influenced by longer-term bond yields, inflation expectations, economic conditions and what financial markets believe the Federal Reserve will do next.

That means a ¼-point Fed increase does not automatically produce a ¼-point increase in mortgage rates tomorrow.

In fact, markets often adjust before the Fed makes its announcement.

Freddie Mac reported that the average 30-year fixed mortgage was 6.76% as of September 10, up from 6.71% the previous week and 6.35% one year earlier.

💰 The bigger housing issue is not the Fed headline itself. It is what elevated borrowing costs do to a buyer’s monthly payment.

A buyer may still qualify for a house.

But the payment may no longer feel comfortable.

And when buyers become payment-sensitive, sellers often have to become more flexible.

Where Are Buyers Gaining Negotiating Power?

Homes That Have Been Sitting on the Market

A newly listed, well-priced home in a desirable location may still receive strong interest.

A house that has been listed for 60, 90 or 120 days is a different conversation.

Longer market time can create opportunities to negotiate:

  • Purchase price
  • Closing costs
  • Repairs
  • Credits
  • Possession
  • Buyer-agent compensation
  • Financing concessions

🎯 The opportunity may not be finding the cheapest house. It may be finding the seller who is finally ready to make a deal.

Homes That Need Work

Buyers tend to become less forgiving when financing is expensive.

If two similar houses are available and one needs a roof, furnace, septic repair or major cosmetic work, buyers are increasingly likely to calculate those costs into their offers.

That creates leverage—but it also gives sellers an opportunity to solve the problem through credits or concessions instead of simply reducing the price.

What Should Northern Michigan Buyers Do Right Now?

Negotiate the Entire Transaction, Not Just the Price

Imagine negotiating $5,000 off the price.

On a 30-year mortgage, that may not dramatically change the monthly payment.

But using that same $5,000 as a seller-paid closing-cost concession or toward an approved mortgage-point buy down may create a much larger immediate benefit for the buyer.

The exact structure depends on the loan program, lender and buyer’s financial situation.

That is why buyers should ask:

“What structure makes this house affordable?”

—not simply—

“How much can I get the seller to reduce the price?”

Look for Motivation

A buyer should know:

  • How long the home has been listed
  • Whether the price has already been reduced
  • Whether the property is vacant
  • Whether the seller has already moved
  • Whether previous offers failed
  • What comparable homes have actually sold for

None of those automatically guarantees a discount.

But together, they help identify where a seller may be more willing to negotiate.

What Should Northern Michigan Sellers Do Right Now?

Price for the Market You Have—Not the Market You Remember

A seller can make a major mistake by pricing based on what happened during the most competitive years.

Home values may still be strong.

That does not mean buyer urgency is equally strong.

📌 Strong prices and slower buyer decision-making can exist at the same time.

An overpriced home can sit while the properly priced house down the road sells.

Think About the Buyer’s Monthly Payment

Sellers tend to think about sale price.

Buyers increasingly think about monthly payment and cash needed to close.

That creates opportunities.

Depending on the transaction, a seller might consider:

  • Closing-cost assistance
  • A mortgage-point buy down
  • Repair credits
  • Completing specific repairs
  • Flexible possession

Those strategies can sometimes solve an affordability problem without requiring the seller to make a large price reduction.

And buyer-agent compensation can matter here as well.

As I explained in Does a Seller Really Have to Pay 6% to List Their House?, a buyer may qualify for the mortgage and still lack enough additional cash to cover every expense required at closing.

Are Northern Michigan Home Prices About to Fall?

Current data does not support making that prediction.

The five-county median price was higher in August than it was a year earlier, even though the number of sales declined. Meanwhile, Wexford and Missaukee experienced more transactions and faster market times while their combined median price declined.

That is a mixed market.

Not a collapse.

Not a runaway seller’s market either.

What I would watch over the next several months is:

  • Active inventory
  • New listings
  • Days on market
  • Price reductions
  • Pending sales
  • Sale-to-list ratios
  • Seller concessions
  • Mortgage rates

Those numbers will tell us whether the shift toward buyers continues.

So, Is Northern Michigan Finally Shifting Toward Buyers?

Yes—but “shifting toward buyers” is different from “being a buyer’s market.”

Buyers have more negotiating opportunities than they did during the most competitive years.

Sellers still have leverage when the property is desirable, properly priced and difficult to replace.

The middle of those two realities is where Northern Michigan appears to be heading.

🏡 Buyers should negotiate intelligently without assuming every seller is desperate.

🏡 Sellers should protect their equity without assuming buyers will accept every price and every term.

That is how deals get made in a more balanced market.

For answers to other common Northern Michigan real estate questions, visit my Northern Michigan Real Estate FAQ.

Use NorMI™ to Analyze Your Specific Situation

NorMI™, the Northern Michigan Real Estate Pro Assistant, can look beyond broad market headlines and help evaluate a particular property, price range or county.

It’s designed to remove confusion — not replace judgment.

Elite NorMI™ Prompt

Click these words to watch NorMI™ perform a high level analysis for your specific situation.

Analyze whether the Northern Michigan housing market is currently shifting toward buyers for my specific property or home search. Compare recent pricing, days on market, sale to list trends, inventory, price reductions, mortgage rate pressure, and negotiation opportunities in Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Antrim, Kalkaska, Wexford, and Missaukee counties. Ask me for the property address, price range, county, and whether I am buying or selling.

For more information:

NorMI™

Conatct Me

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Northern Michigan a buyer’s market in 2026?

Not broadly. Buyers are gaining negotiating leverage in some locations and price ranges, but August 2026 data still shows strong prices and active demand throughout much of Northern Michigan.

Did the Federal Reserve raise interest rates on September 16, 2026?

Yes. The Federal Reserve raised its federal funds target range by ¼ percentage point to 3.75%–4.00% on September 16, 2026. The Fed said inflation remains elevated.

Does a Fed rate increase automatically raise mortgage rates?

No. The Federal Reserve does not directly set 30-year mortgage rates. Mortgage rates are influenced by longer-term interest rates, inflation expectations and expectations about future economic and Federal Reserve policy.

Do Northern Michigan buyers have more negotiating power now?

In many situations, yes. Listings with longer market times, previous price reductions, condition issues or limited buyer activity may give buyers more opportunity to negotiate price, closing costs, repairs or financing concessions.

What should Northern Michigan sellers do if buyers are becoming more selective?

Price according to current comparable sales and evaluate the entire offer rather than just the headline purchase price. Closing-cost assistance, point buy downs, repairs, possession terms or other concessions may sometimes solve a buyer affordability issue while still protecting the seller’s net proceeds.

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, the Northern Michigan housing market is becoming more balanced, giving buyers additional negotiating opportunities without creating a broad buyer’s market. Home prices remain strong in many areas, but elevated mortgage rates and affordability pressure mean buyers and sellers may need to use pricing, concessions and other negotiation strategies to make transactions work.

Voice Assistant Answer

Northern Michigan is shifting somewhat toward buyers, but it is not broadly a buyer’s market. Prices remain strong in many areas, while higher mortgage rates are creating affordability pressure and giving some buyers more negotiating room. The best opportunities depend heavily on the property, location, price range and how long it has been on the market.

Was 6% Ever the Standard Real Estate Commission in Northern Michigan?

See Transcript

Episode 20, 9/14/2026

Corresponding Blog: Does a Seller Really Have to Pay 6% to List Their House?

Episode Summary

Was 6% ever the standard real estate commission? Six percent became a common benchmark in many U.S. real estate markets, but there has not been a nationally required 6% commission, and brokerage compensation is negotiable. The recent real estate commission changes did not suddenly make commissions negotiable; they changed important parts of how buyer-agent compensation is communicated and handled.

Full Transcript

Introduction

[00:10]

Welcome to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence. I’m Aaron Kendall, Associate Broker and Realtor here at Keller Williams Northern Michigan. Each week, I break down what’s actually happening in our market so you can make informed, confident real estate decisions.

This week, I want to take a closer look at a number almost everyone associates with selling a house: six percent.

[00:33]

For years, people have heard some version of this:

“The standard real estate commission is six percent.”

But was six percent actually the standard? Was it a rule? Was it required? And did the recent commission lawsuits suddenly change all of that?

The answer is more nuanced than some of the headlines make it sound.

So, as we move through September 2026, I want to separate three things that often get blended together: what was common in the marketplace, what was actually required, and what sellers should understand today.

[01:07]

The Core Topic

[01:08]

First, six percent was never a nationally required commission that every seller had to pay.

There was no federal law saying a homeowner had to pay six percent to sell a house. And in the modern real estate system, the National Association of REALTORS® has not established six percent as a required commission rate.

Brokerage compensation is negotiable.

But there is another side to this story that is important if we want to be accurate.

Six percent did become a very familiar number in residential real estate. For decades, total commission in many markets commonly fell somewhere around five to six percent. So when consumers started referring to six percent as “the standard,” that perception did not simply appear out of nowhere.

Historically, the real estate industry also had periods when local real estate boards used commission schedules or recommended rates. Those practices became the subject of antitrust scrutiny many decades ago, and the industry changed considerably over time.

That history matters because there is a difference between saying six percent was common or conventional commission and saying six percent was a legally required national standard.

Those are not the same statement.

[02:26]

In a traditional transaction, the seller would often enter into a listing agreement that established the total brokerage compensation. The listing broker could then offer part of that compensation to the broker who brought the buyer.

That structure helped make the six-percent idea especially visible to consumers because they often saw one total percentage associated with the transaction, even though that money could ultimately compensate multiple brokers and agents involved in the sale.

But different brokerages could charge different amounts. Different transactions could be structured differently. And compensation could be negotiated.

So if somebody tells you that every seller used to be required to pay six percent until the recent lawsuits changed the rules; that is not an accurate description of what happened.

[03:16]

Market Explanation

[03:17]

This became especially confusing after the National Association of REALTORS® settlement and the rule changes that took effect in 2024.

A lot of headlines made it sound as though six-percent commissions had suddenly been abolished, or that real estate commissions had become negotiable for the first time.

Neither description is quite right.

Compensation was already negotiable.

[03:40]

What changed included the way compensation for a buyer’s broker is handled and communicated. Offers of buyer-broker compensation can no longer be displayed through participating Multiple Listing Services, and buyers working with an agent need a written agreement before touring homes, whether in person or virtually.

That agreement needs to address the services being provided and the compensation arrangement.

Sellers can still choose to contribute toward a buyer’s brokerage costs. Buyers can negotiate compensation with their own agent. And the parties can negotiate different ways of handling those costs as part of a transaction.

[04:19]

That brings us back to the six-percent question.

The useful conversation for a seller in Northern Michigan is not really, “Is six percent still the standard?”

I don’t think there is much value in starting there.

The better questions are: What is this brokerage charging me? What services am I receiving? What other costs or compensation might be involved in the transaction? And, most importantly, what does the entire offer mean for my final net proceeds?

That matters because the lowest commission does not automatically produce the highest net to the seller.

But the reverse is also true. A higher fee does not automatically mean better representation or a better result.

You have to evaluate the actual service, the marketing plan, the experience of the agent, the property itself, the expected buyer pool, and the terms of the eventual offer.

[05:14]

The buyer side deserves the same kind of careful thinking.

Suppose a buyer has agreed in writing to compensate their agent. Depending on the transaction, the buyer may ask the seller to contribute toward that cost.

A seller can evaluate that request as part of the offer.

And that is where I think consumers are better served by looking at the entire transaction rather than becoming fixated on one percentage.

An offer with one compensation structure might still leave a seller with more money than another offer with a lower commission or compensation expense.

Price matters. Financing matters. Concessions matter. Inspection terms matter. Closing costs matter. And brokerage compensation matters.

The final net is what brings all of those numbers together.

[06:01]

I went into some of these issues in more detail in this week’s corresponding blog post, “Does a Seller Really Have to Pay 6% to List Their House?” You can find that in the blog section at AaronKendallRealEstate.com.

The main point I want people to take away from this episode is fairly simple.

Six percent became a familiar and commonly used number in residential real estate. Calling it a historical convention in many markets is reasonable.

Calling it a nationally required commission is not.

And saying the recent settlement suddenly made commissions negotiable for the first time is not accurate either.

As of September 2026, compensation remains negotiable.

For sellers here in Northern Michigan, that means you should understand exactly what you are agreeing to before signing a listing agreement.

Ask what the brokerage is charging.

Ask what services are included.

Ask how buyer-agent compensation may come into the transaction.

And when an offer arrives, look at the entire financial picture rather than isolating one number.

That’s a much more useful way to make the decision.

[07:07]

Wrap Up

[07:09]

So, was six percent ever the standard real estate commission?

If by “standard” you mean a common number that became deeply established in the real estate marketplace, six percent certainly became a familiar benchmark.

If by “standard” you mean a nationally required rate that every seller had to pay, no.

That distinction is important because it keeps us from replacing one oversimplification with another.

Real estate compensation has changed, particularly in how buyer-agent compensation is communicated and negotiated. But the basic principle that brokerage compensation is negotiable is not new.

If you’re selling a home in Northern Michigan, the goal shouldn’t be to chase a supposedly standard percentage.

Understand what you’re paying for, understand your options, and evaluate the numbers based on what you actually expect to net from the sale.

If you found this episode useful, follow or subscribe to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence, and look for next week’s episode as we continue breaking down the issues affecting Northern Michigan buyers, sellers, and property owners.

[08:17]

Elite NorMI™ Prompt

[08:19]

If you’d like to dive deeper on this, you can ask NorMI™ something like: “If I sell my Northern Michigan home, explain how listing broker compensation, buyer-agent compensation, seller concessions, and the sale price can affect my final net proceeds.”

If you are following along on the transcript, just click on those words and watch NorMI™ analyze your specific situation.

Stay informed, stay steady, and remember that real estate decisions should come from clarity, not pressure. I’ll talk with you next week.

[08:51]

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, 6% became a familiar and commonly used real estate commission benchmark, but there has not been a nationally required 6% commission that every seller must pay. Brokerage compensation is negotiable, and sellers should evaluate the services provided, potential buyer-agent compensation, other transaction costs, and their expected final net proceeds rather than relying on a supposedly standard percentage.

Voice Assistant Block

Voice Assistant Answer: Six percent became a common real estate commission benchmark in many markets, but it has not been a nationally required rate that every seller must pay. Real estate brokerage compensation is negotiable. Sellers should focus on what services they receive, how compensation is structured, and what they will actually net from the sale.

Does a Seller Really Have to Pay 6% to List Their House?

AI Overview

No. A seller does not have to pay 6% to list a house, and real estate commissions have never been set by law at a standard rate. The 2024 NAR settlement changed how buyer-agent compensation is disclosed and negotiated, but sellers can still negotiate their listing fee and decide whether contributing toward a buyer’s agent compensation makes financial sense.

For years, one of the most persistent beliefs in real estate has been:

“It costs 6% to sell a house.”

That number became so familiar that many consumers assumed it was a rule.

It wasn’t.

💰 There has never been a law requiring a seller to pay a 6% real estate commission.

There has never been a National Association of REALTORS® rule establishing 6% as the required commission either. Broker fees and commissions are negotiable.

The recent commission lawsuits did not suddenly make commissions negotiable.

They already were.

What changed was primarily how compensation—especially compensation for the agent representing the buyer—is disclosed and negotiated.

Was 6% Ever the Standard Real Estate Commission?

No—There Has Never Been a Required Standard Commission

Six percent became deeply embedded in public perception because many transactions historically involved compensation to both the listing side and the buyer side.

That does not mean every seller paid 6%.

It does not mean every brokerage charged 6%.

And it certainly does not mean 6% was legally required.

One brokerage may charge one amount. Another may charge something different. Compensation can be structured as a percentage, flat fee, or another negotiated arrangement.

🏡 The better question is not “What is the standard commission?”

It is:

“What am I paying, what am I receiving for it, and what will I actually net when my house sells?”

What Did the Real Estate Commission Lawsuit Actually Change?

The litigation that resulted in the National Association of REALTORS® settlement challenged longstanding industry practices involving broker compensation.

NAR agreed in 2024 to a $418 million settlement while denying wrongdoing. The settlement received final approval in November 2024, and the Eighth Circuit upheld the broader settlement on appeal in August 2026.

Beginning August 17, 2024, offers of buyer-broker compensation could no longer be communicated through participating MLS systems.

REALTORS® working with buyers also became required to enter into written buyer agreements before touring a home (whether in-person or virtual). Those agreements must specify how the buyer broker will be compensated, and that compensation cannot simply be left open-ended.

🚨 What did NOT happen is just as important: sellers were not prohibited from paying a buyer’s agent.

Seller-paid buyer-broker compensation can still be negotiated outside the MLS.

The negotiation did not disappear.

It moved.

What Does a Seller Actually Pay to List a House?

There are really two separate compensation conversations.

First, the seller and listing brokerage negotiate what the listing brokerage will be paid. If you look in your Listing Agreement under the Compensation section, you are virtually guaranteed to find a statement that says commissions are not set by law and are negotiable.

Second, the seller decides whether to contribute toward compensation for the buyer’s broker.

Neither one has a universal required percentage.

A seller should compare the fee with the services, marketing, strategy, negotiation, experience, and expected seller net.

📊 A low fee is not automatically a bargain, and a higher fee does not automatically mean better service.

For other common transaction questions, see my Northern Michigan Real Estate FAQ.

Does the Seller Have to Pay the Buyer’s Agent?

No.

But that is different from saying a seller should never consider doing it.

Under today’s system, the buyer typically has a written agreement with their broker establishing how that broker will be compensated.

If the buyer has agreed to compensate their agent and the seller does not contribute enough toward that amount, the buyer may have to pay the difference themselves.

And buyers already need cash for:

  • Down payment
  • Loan closing costs
  • Taxes and insurance
  • Inspection and appraisal
  • Moving expenses
  • Repairs or improvements

💡 A buyer can have excellent credit, enough income to qualify for the mortgage, and still not have several thousand additional dollars available to pay their agent in cash.

Why Would a Seller Pay Buyer-Agent Compensation If They Don’t Have To?

Because real estate operates in the real world—not just on paper.

Imagine a buyer can afford the payment on a $400,000 home and has enough money for the down payment and normal closing costs.

But they do not have another several thousand dollars available to satisfy their buyer-agent agreement.

If the seller agrees to contribute toward that expense from the sale proceeds, the buyer may be able to complete the transaction without producing the same amount as additional cash.

In practical terms, that cost becomes part of the overall economics of the sale.

That does not mean you simply add commission to the asking price and magically make the house worth more.

The buyer still has to accept the price.

The property still has to compete with comparable homes.

And the appraisal still matters.

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have both recognized that customary seller-paid costs can receive different treatment from ordinary financing concessions; Freddie Mac specifically addressed customary seller-paid buyer-agent fees in its guidance.

And the listing price was almost certainly calculated by using comps which included the buyer broker commission in the first place. It’s not realistic to base the price of the home on the comps that included buyer broker commission, but then turn around and expect not to contribute to the buyer side.

Who Really Pays the Real Estate Commission—the Buyer or the Seller?

This is mostly an argument over semantics.

If compensation is deducted from seller proceeds at closing, it is perfectly accurate to say:

“The seller paid the commission.”

But where did the seller’s proceeds come from?

The buyer.

The buyer brings cash and usually mortgage proceeds into the transaction. Those funds become the seller’s sale proceeds, from which mortgages, taxes, title expenses, commissions, and other obligations are paid.

So someone saying:

“The buyer ultimately brought the money that paid everything.”

also has a point.

It’s like arguing over who paid the truck driver that brought the gallon of milk to the grocery store. Sure, the store wrote the check–but the customer gave the store the money to be able do that in the first place.

🎯 The questions that actually matter are who is contractually obligated to pay, how much cash the buyer needs to close, and what the seller ultimately nets.

Can Refusing Buyer-Agent Compensation Reduce My Buyer Pool?

Yes, absolutely. And in some cases, the seller may never even know it happened.

A serious buyer does not always schedule a showing the moment they see a house online.

A good buyer’s agent will gather additional information first—things that may not be obvious from the public listing. That can include occupancy, possession, utilities, association issues and dues, property condition, offer instructions, and buyer-agent compensation.

The agent gathers that information and sends it back to the buyer so the buyer can decide whether the property still makes sense before spending time touring it. Buyers can, and often do, disqualify a house from a tour based on any, or all of those factors.

Buyer-agent compensation can absolutely be one of those deciding factors.

Suppose the buyer has already agreed in writing to compensate their agent.

The buyer asks about a house they like.

Their agent contacts the listing agent with several property questions, and also learns that the seller is offering no buyer-agent compensation—or an amount substantially below what the buyer has already agreed to pay.

Now the buyer has to calculate the difference.

If that means bringing another several thousand dollars to closing on top of the down payment, lender costs, inspections, appraisal, insurance, and other expenses, the buyer may simply decide:

“I can’t financially make this house work.”

And they never tour it.

🏡 The seller may lose that buyer before the buyer ever walks through the front door.

That is not steering.

The agent did their job by obtaining and providing the information to the buyer. The buyer then made the financial decision.

NAR policy prohibits MLS participants from filtering or restricting listings communicated to buyers based on the existence or amount of compensation.

But buyers are still allowed to decide what they can and can’t afford.

A seller may never know how many buyers saw the listing, asked their agent for additional information, learned what their out-of-pocket obligation would be, and quietly moved on to another property.

That is one of the biggest practical realities missing from a lot of the post-lawsuit commission discussion.

Does Offering No Buyer-Agent Compensation Automatically Save the Seller Money?

Not necessarily.

It may save money.

It may also increase the buyer’s required cash, affect an offer, shift the compensation request into the purchase contract, or remove financially constrained buyers before they ever tour the home.

📌 “I’m not required to pay it” and “there is no financial reason to consider paying it” are two completely different statements.

The seller should evaluate the complete transaction:

Price + expenses + terms + likelihood of closing + seller net.

What Should a Northern Michigan Seller Ask Before Listing?

Before signing a listing agreement, ask:

  • What exactly am I paying the listing brokerage?
  • What services and marketing are included?
  • Am I agreeing to contribute toward buyer-broker compensation?
  • Can buyer-agent compensation instead be negotiated when an offer arrives?
  • How could that decision affect buyer affordability?
  • What other seller expenses should I expect?
  • What will my estimated net proceeds be?
  • How will competing offers be compared based on net, rather than just purchase price?

📊 Understand the numbers before the sign goes in the yard—not three days before closing.

Use NorMI™ to Compare the Numbers Instead of Guessing

NorMI™, the Northern Michigan Real Estate Pro Assistant, can help compare different compensation structures against the numbers that actually matter.

It’s designed to remove confusion — not replace judgment.

Elite NorMI™ Prompt:

Click on the words below to watch NorMI™ perform a high level analysis of your situation.

Analyze the different real estate commission and buyer broker compensation options for selling my Northern Michigan home.Please explain that commissions are negotiable and do not assume a standard rate. Compare my estimated seller net under different listing broker fees and buyer broker compensation options.In your analysis, consider: My mortgage payoff, Michigan transfer taxes, Typical seller closing costs, Seller concessions, Buyer cash requirements, Whether a buyer could decide not to tour the property because their out-of-pocket buyer broker obligation is too high. Explain the tradeoffs involved and ask me for the property address, expected sale price, mortgage payoff, and the compensation options I am considering.

For more information:

NorMI™

Contact Me

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a seller have to pay 6% commission to sell a house?

No. There is no law or standard requiring a seller to pay a 6% real estate commission, and brokerage compensation is negotiable. Broker fees and commissions are not set by law, and never have been.

Did the NAR lawsuit eliminate real estate commissions?

No. The settlement changed how buyer-agent compensation is disclosed and removed offers of buyer-broker compensation from participating MLS systems. Sellers can still negotiate buyer-broker compensation outside the MLS.

Does a seller have to pay the buyer’s real estate agent?

No. Seller-paid buyer-agent compensation is negotiable. However, if the buyer has agreed to compensate their broker and cannot afford the full amount in additional cash, they may ask the seller to contribute, or move on to another house that will.

Could a buyer skip my house if I refuse buyer-agent compensation?

Yes. A buyer may ask their agent to gather compensation and other transaction details before scheduling a showing. If the seller is not contributing enough toward the buyer-agent compensation the buyer has already agreed to pay, the additional cash required may make the property financially unrealistic, causing the buyer to eliminate it before ever touring the home.

Who really pays the real estate commission?

Contractually, whoever agreed to pay the brokerage compensation is responsible. Economically, the cost can affect both the buyer’s total transaction cost and the seller’s final net proceeds.

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, sellers have never been required to pay a standard 6% real estate commission because brokerage compensation is negotiable, and always has been. Sellers should evaluate listing fees and buyer-agent compensation based not only on cost, but also on buyer affordability, potential showing activity, offer structure, and their final net proceeds.

Voice Assistant Answer

No, a seller does not have to pay 6% to list a house. Real estate commissions have always been negotiable. Sellers can also decide whether to contribute toward buyer-agent compensation, but refusing to do so may increase a buyer’s required cash enough that some otherwise qualified buyers decide not to pursue the property and move on to others that will.

How Does a Septic System and Drainfield Actually Work in a Northern Michigan Home?

See Transcript

Episode 19, 9/3/2026

How Does a Septic System and Drainfield Actually Work in a Northern Michigan Home?

Corresponding blog: How Do Septic Systems Work?

Episode Summary

A septic system treats household wastewater in two main stages: the septic tank separates and holds solids, while liquid wastewater flows into the drainfield where the surrounding soil provides additional treatment and dispersal. Understanding that relationship is especially important for Northern Michigan homeowners because protecting the drainfield is one of the most important parts of keeping a septic system functioning properly.

Full Transcript

Introduction

[00:10]

Welcome to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence. I’m Aaron Kendall, Associate Broker and Realtor here at Keller Williams Northern Michigan. Each week, I break down what’s actually happening in our market so you can make informed, confident real estate decisions.

This week, we’re going underneath the yard.

If you own a home with a septic system, you’ve probably heard people talk about pumping the tank, inspecting the septic, or worrying about the drainfield.

But what is actually happening down there?

Because a septic tank isn’t just a big underground container that holds everything until somebody comes and pumps it out.

And the drainfield isn’t simply a place where wastewater disappears.

They’re two different parts of a wastewater treatment system, and understanding what each one actually does makes septic ownership a lot easier to understand.

[01:01]

The Core Topic

[01:02]

Let’s start inside the house.

Every time you flush a toilet, take a shower, run the dishwasher, do laundry, or drain a sink, that wastewater has to go somewhere.

If you’re connected to municipal sewer, it leaves your property and eventually goes to a wastewater treatment facility.

With a private septic system, the treatment process happens right on your property.

In a conventional system, wastewater leaves the house through a main drainage pipe and enters a buried, watertight septic tank.  It’s typically within 5-15 feet of your house, often near a corner.  You can usually find the exact location by searching your local health department records for your property.  Many times you can find it online and it’s a free search (usually).

Septic tanks are usually made of concrete, fiberglass, or polyethylene plastic.  They often range from 500 gallons to over 2,000 gallons, but most 3-5 bedroom homes are generally 1,000—1,600 gallon tanks.  Your local Health Department code determines the size of the tank, based on the amount of bedrooms your house has.  ***Keep this in mind if you are considering making additions to your house in the future.*** 

Now, inside that septic tank, gravity starts doing some of the work.

The heavier solids settle toward the bottom. That material forms what’s called sludge.

Fats, oils, grease, and lighter materials tend to float toward the top and form what’s called the scum layer.

Between those two layers is mostly liquid wastewater, called effluent.

That’s important because the septic tank is designed to keep most of those solids inside the tank while allowing the liquid portion to continue through the system.

Baffles and other components help prevent the sludge and floating material from simply flowing straight out toward the drainfield.

And this explains something that I think a lot of homeowners misunderstand about septic tanks.

A properly operating septic tank normally contains liquid.

When somebody pumps your septic tank, they’re not doing it because the tank became “full” like a garbage can.

They’re removing the sludge and scum that have accumulated inside it.

After the tank is pumped and you start using water again, the tank fills with wastewater again. That’s normal.  Within a couple days the septic tank will become full of liquid again.

The real concern is how much solid material is accumulating inside that tank.

Because if you allow enough sludge and scum to build up, eventually solids can begin moving out of the tank with the liquid.

And where do they go?

Into the drainfield.

That’s when a maintenance issue can start becoming a much more serious problem.

[03:50]

Market Explanation

[03:51]

The drainfield is really the part of the system I want homeowners and buyers to understand.

The septic tank does some initial treatment and separates the solids from the wastewater.

But the drainfield and the soil are doing a huge part of the actual wastewater treatment.

Liquid effluent leaves the septic tank and is distributed through the pipes, trenches, chambers, or another approved system into the drainfield.

That drainfield is generally located in relatively shallow, unsaturated soil.

As the wastewater moves through the soil, natural biological processes help remove harmful bacteria, viruses, and some nutrients.

Eventually, that treated water moves farther into the soil and groundwater system.

So when you look out into the yard and see grass growing over the drainfield, there is actually a wastewater-treatment process happening underneath it.

And that is why protecting the drainfield matters so much.

The drainfield needs the soil to accept the wastewater.

If you continuously overload the system with more water than it can handle, the soil may not be able to absorb it quickly enough.

If solids escape from the septic tank and reach the drainfield, they can clog the soil and interfere with its ability to accept and treat wastewater.

If you drive heavy vehicles or equipment over the drainfield, you can compact the soil or potentially damage components underneath it.

And if you build something over it, you can create another set of problems.

That’s why pumping the septic tank is really about protecting the entire system.

You’re removing accumulated solids before those solids have an opportunity to migrate into the drainfield.

A tank can be pumped.

A failing drainfield is a much different problem.

Once the soil can no longer properly accept and treat wastewater, you may start seeing slow drains inside the house, toilets that don’t flush properly, sewage backing up, gassy odors outside, unusually wet areas over the drainfield, or wastewater actually reaching the surface.

At that point, pumping the tank may temporarily relieve some symptoms, but it doesn’t necessarily repair whatever has happened to the drainfield.

And this becomes especially relevant in Northern Michigan because private septic systems are extremely common.

Michigan EGLE estimates roughly 35 percent of Michigan residents rely on private septic systems.

Here in Northern Michigan, we also have conditions that can make understanding the system particularly important.

We have rural homes, seasonal cottages, waterfront properties, private wells, sandy soils, high groundwater in some areas, and homes that may have been expanded considerably since their original septic systems were installed.

You might have a cottage that was originally built as a two-bedroom seasonal property decades ago.

Over time, somebody adds bedrooms, converts space, finishes another level, or starts using the property much more heavily.

The house changed.

But did the septic system change with it?

That’s something I want to know when I’m helping someone evaluate a property.

Because septic capacity isn’t always determined by how many beds you can physically fit inside the bedrooms.

This is also why short-term rentals deserve some extra thought.

A house that normally has two people living in it may behave very differently when eight or ten vacation guests arrive and everybody showers, runs the dishwasher, does laundry, and uses the bathrooms within a relatively short period.

The septic system doesn’t care how much rental income the property generates.

It still has a physical amount of wastewater it was designed to handle.

And then there is waterfront property.

The drainfield isn’t just protecting your plumbing.

Proper wastewater treatment helps protect groundwater and the lakes and streams that make Northern Michigan waterfront property so desirable in the first place.

That’s why soil conditions, groundwater separation, system design, and proper operation matter.

The goal isn’t simply to make wastewater disappear from the house.

The goal is to treat it safely before it returns to the environment.

And once you understand that, a lot of septic advice suddenly makes more sense.

Why shouldn’t you flush wipes, grease, and other garbage?

Because you don’t want unnecessary solids entering the system.

Why shouldn’t you run six loads of laundry back-to-back if you can avoid it?

Because you’re sending a large volume of water through the system in a short period.

Why do you pump the tank periodically?

To remove accumulated solids before they reach the drainfield.

Why shouldn’t you park an RV or build a garage over the drainfield?

Because that soil and the components underneath it are part of your wastewater-treatment system.

And why do I care so much about where the septic tank and drainfield are located when somebody is buying property?

Because that area of the yard isn’t just empty land.

It is working infrastructure.

If you’re thinking about adding a garage, pole barn, swimming pool, driveway, or addition later, the location of the septic system can affect what you can realistically do with the property.

That’s the part I think buyers sometimes overlook.

They see the house.

They see the acreage.

They see a big open backyard and start imagining what they’ll build there someday.

Meanwhile, part of that open area may be occupied by the drainfield or reserved for future septic needs.

So when you’re buying a Northern Michigan property with a private septic system, don’t just ask, “Does the septic work?”

Find out where the tank is.

Find out where the drainfield is.

Find out what the system was designed to serve.

And understand that the tank and drainfield are not interchangeable pieces.

The tank primarily separates and retains solids.

The drainfield and soil take the liquid wastewater and continue the treatment process.

They need each other to work to make the whole system function properly.

I went considerably deeper into septic maintenance, pumping schedules, warning signs, what shouldn’t go down your drains, system lifespan, and Northern Michigan inspection requirements in this week’s blog, “How Do Septic Systems Work?”

You can find that in the blog section on my website.  Or, if you are following along on the transcript, you can click the link here (https://aaronkendallrealestate.com/how-do-septic-systems-work/).

But if you remember only one thing from today’s episode, make it this:

Your septic tank isn’t where the wastewater-treatment process ends.

It’s where it begins.

Protecting the tank helps protect the drainfield, and protecting the drainfield helps protect the property and the environment around it.

[10:47]

Wrap Up

[10:49]

If you’re buying a home with a septic system, understanding those two pieces gives you a much better starting point for asking the right questions.

You don’t have to become a septic expert.

But you should understand what you’re buying, where the system is located, and why proper maintenance matters.  This is one of the many things I always make sure to verify when working with my buyers.

If you found this episode helpful, follow or subscribe to the podcast, and look for next week’s episode as we continue breaking down the practical issues Northern Michigan homeowners and buyers should understand.

[11:23]

Elite NorMI™ Prompt

[11:25]

If you’d like to dive deeper on this, you can ask NorMI™ something like:

Analyze what I should investigate about the septic system before buying this Northern Michigan property. Identify the local septic requirements and help me research the tank, drainfield, system age, capacity, maintenance history, bedroom count, and whether the property has been expanded since the system was installed. The property address is:

If you are following along on the transcript, just click those words and watch NorMI™ automatically begin to analyze your specific property.  Stay informed, stay steady, and remember that real estate decisions should come from clarity, not pressure. I’ll talk with you next week.

[12:07]

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, a septic tank and drainfield perform different parts of the same wastewater-treatment process. The tank separates and retains solids while liquid wastewater moves into the drainfield, where the soil provides additional treatment and dispersal, making protection of the drainfield an important part of maintaining the entire system.

Voice Assistant Block

Voice Assistant Answer: A septic tank holds household wastewater long enough for solids to settle and oils and grease to float, while the remaining liquid flows into the drainfield. The drainfield distributes that wastewater into unsaturated soil, where natural processes provide additional treatment before the water eventually moves into the groundwater system.

How Do Septic Systems Work?

AI Overview

A septic system treats wastewater on your own property by separating solids inside a buried septic tank and sending the remaining liquid into a drainfield, where the soil provides additional treatment. Most household septic systems should be inspected about every three years and typically pumped every three to five years, although tank size, household size, water use, garbage-disposal use, and the type of system can change that schedule.

If you live outside a municipal sewer system in Northern Michigan, there is a good chance everything leaving your toilets, showers, sinks, dishwasher, and washing machine eventually ends up in a wastewater-treatment system located somewhere in your own yard.

For most homeowners, that system quietly does its job for years without much attention.

That is both the good news and the problem.

🚽 A septic system can be remarkably dependable, but “out of sight, out of mind” is one of the easiest ways to turn routine maintenance into an expensive failure.

Understanding what is underneath the yard—and what it needs from you—can help protect your home, your wallet, your drinking water, and Northern Michigan’s lakes and groundwater.

How Does a Septic System Work?

Most conventional residential septic systems have two major parts:

  • The septic tank
  • The drainfield, sometimes called a leach field or soil absorption field

Wastewater leaves the house through one main pipe and enters the buried septic tank. Inside the tank, the wastewater separates into layers.

Heavy solids settle to the bottom and form sludge.

Fats, oils, grease, and other lighter material float to the top and form scum.

The liquid in between, called effluent, eventually flows out of the tank and into the drainfield.

Baffles and outlet components are designed to keep most of the solids inside the tank instead of allowing them to travel into the drainfield.

What Does the Septic Drainfield Do?

The drainfield is not simply an empty area where wastewater disappears.

The liquid leaving the tank is distributed through pipes or chambers into unsaturated soil. The soil then filters, treats, and disperses that wastewater as it moves downward.

A properly functioning drainfield helps remove harmful bacteria, viruses, and nutrients before the water eventually reaches groundwater.

🌲 The tank and the drainfield work together. Pumping protects the tank, but one of the main reasons you pump the tank is to protect the drainfield.

How Often Should a Septic Tank Be Pumped?

For a typical household, every three to five years is a reasonable starting point.

The EPA recommends having an average household septic system inspected at least every three years and says septic tanks are typically pumped every three to five years. Systems containing pumps, electrical components, or other mechanical treatment equipment may require more frequent inspection.

But that does not mean everyone should automatically wait five years.

What Determines How Often My Septic Tank Needs Pumping?

Pumping frequency can depend on:

  • Septic tank size
  • Number of people living in the home
  • Amount of wastewater being generated
  • Amount of solids entering the system
  • Garbage-disposal use
  • Whether the home is occupied year-round or seasonally
  • Whether the property is used as a short-term rental
  • Type and age of the septic system

A retired couple living in a home six months of the year may put far less demand on a system than a family of six.

A busy vacation rental can be another story.

Eight guests taking showers, doing laundry, washing dishes, and using bathrooms in a short period can put substantial demand on a system that may originally have been designed for a much smaller household.

💡 The number of beds you can physically fit into a Northern Michigan vacation home does not tell you how many people the septic system was designed to serve.

What Happens If You Never Pump a Septic Tank?

This is probably the most important thing for a homeowner to understand.

A septic tank is normally full of liquid.

You are not pumping it because the tank eventually becomes “full” in the same way a garbage can becomes full.

You pump it because the layers of sludge and scum continue accumulating.

If enough solids build up, they can begin escaping from the tank and entering the drainfield.

Once solids reach the drainfield, they can clog the soil and interfere with its ability to accept and treat wastewater. Poor maintenance and solids migrating into the drainfield are recognized causes of septic-system failure.

⚠️ A pump-out is maintenance. A damaged drainfield can become excavation, replacement, permits, soil evaluations, and thousands of dollars.

That is a very different problem.

What Are the Warning Signs That a Septic System Is Failing?

A septic system does not always fail dramatically overnight.

Watch for:

  • Toilets, showers, tubs, or sinks draining slowly
  • Gurgling plumbing
  • Sewage backing up inside the house
  • Sewage odors indoors or outside
  • Standing water or unusually wet ground near the tank or drainfield
  • Spongy ground above the system
  • Unusually bright green grass over part of the drainfield during otherwise dry conditions

The EPA identifies these as common warning signs of a malfunctioning septic system.

If sewage is surfacing outside or backing into the home, avoid direct contact and contact a septic professional.

What Should Never Go Into a Septic System?

Your toilet is not a garbage disposal.

Neither is your kitchen sink.

Michigan EGLE recommends flushing only human waste and toilet paper and specifically warns against putting items such as wipes, grease, feminine hygiene products, diapers, dental floss, cigarette butts, coffee grounds, and other inappropriate materials into a septic system.

And yes, that includes many products marketed as “flushable” wipes.

Water matters too.

Fix leaking toilets and faucets, avoid unnecessarily large bursts of water use, and consider spreading laundry loads throughout the week rather than running several loads back-to-back.

💧 A septic system handles wastewater over time. Dumping large volumes into it all at once can overload the system.

Can You Drive, Build, or Plant Over a Septic Drainfield?

Generally, keep vehicles, heavy equipment, buildings, and other major loads away from the drainfield.

Compacted soil can interfere with the drainfield’s ability to absorb wastewater, and heavy equipment can damage buried components.

Before building a garage, pole barn, addition, pool, driveway, or other improvement, know where the tank and drainfield are located.

Grass is usually appropriate over a drainfield.

Large trees and deep-rooted vegetation deserve more caution because roots can interfere with components of the system.

How Long Does a Septic System Last?

There is no universal expiration date.

EPA guidance says concrete septic tanks can sometimes last 50 years or more, while pumps and controls may require replacement much sooner. Drainfields can gradually lose effectiveness as they age, and EPA specifically notes that systems with drainfields older than roughly 25 to 30 years deserve additional planning and attention.

Actual life expectancy depends on:

  • Soil conditions
  • Groundwater
  • Original design
  • Installation quality
  • Amount of use
  • Maintenance history
  • Tank material
  • Drainfield condition

That is why I care about more than just the answer to “How old is the septic system?”

I also want to know:

How has it been maintained, and how is it functioning today?

Why Do Septic Systems Matter So Much in Northern Michigan?

Northern Michigan has private wells, sandy soils, lakes, rivers, seasonal cottages, waterfront homes, rural properties, and vacation rentals.

A failed septic system is not simply a plumbing inconvenience.

Untreated wastewater can introduce bacteria, viruses, nutrients, and other contaminants into groundwater and surface water.

🌊 If you own waterfront property, taking care of your septic system is also part of protecting the water that makes the property desirable in the first place.

Do I Need a Septic Inspection When I Sell a Northern Michigan Home?

Sometimes.

The requirements are not identical across Northern Michigan.

Benzie and Leelanau counties have Time of Transfer requirements involving onsite well and septic systems when property ownership changes.

Grand Traverse County also implemented a Time of Transfer program beginning January 1, 2026. It applies to qualifying homes served by a well and/or septic system when the dwelling is located within 300 feet of surface water. The system must be evaluated before the transfer can be finalized.

Other counties can have different requirements. Even inside a county, certain townships can develop their own rules, like Long Lake Township in Traverse City. Many townships require a septic system evaluation in order to Short Term Rent (STR) a property.

📍 Never assume that the septic rules from one Northern Michigan county automatically apply in the next county.

What Should I Ask About a Septic System Before Buying a House?

Before buying, I would want to know:

  • Where are the tank and drainfield located?
  • When was the tank last pumped?
  • Are pumping or maintenance records available?
  • How old is the system?
  • What size is the tank?
  • How many bedrooms was the system designed to serve?
  • Has the house been expanded since the septic system was installed?
  • Have there been repairs or drainfield replacements?
  • Are permits or health-department records available?
  • Is there evidence of backups, odors, wet areas, or drainage problems?
  • Does the county require a Time of Transfer or other evaluation?

A house can flush perfectly during a 30-minute showing and still have a septic problem.

That is why records and proper inspection matter.

Can NorMI™ Help Me Research a Septic System Before Buying?

NorMI™, the Northern Michigan Real Estate Pro Assistant, can help identify the jurisdiction, organize the records you should look for, and develop the right questions before you buy a property with a private septic system.

It’s designed to remove confusion — not replace judgment.

Elite NorMI™ Prompt

Click on this prompt below to have NorMI™ pre fill the question for you and all you have to do is add the address and hit submit. Watch NorMI™ analyze a specific address you are considering.

Analyze what I should investigate about the septic system before buying this Northern Michigan property. Identify the county and local health department, whether a time-of-transfer or other septic evaluation may apply, what records I should look for, questions to ask about the tank, drainfield, system age, capacity, last pumping, repairs, bedroom count, waterfront location, and whether the property has been expanded since the system was installed. Explain which findings would justify additional inspection by a septic professional or local health department. Do not determine that the system is safe or provide engineering advice. The property address is

For additional Northern Michigan real estate guidance:

NorMI™

Frequently Asked Questions

Contact Me

How often should I pump my septic tank?

Most household septic tanks are typically pumped every three to five years, although actual frequency depends on tank size, household size, water use, and the amount of solids entering the system. EPA guidance recommends regular inspection rather than relying only on the calendar.

What happens if I never pump my septic tank?

Solids continue accumulating and can eventually leave the tank and enter the drainfield. Those solids can clog the drainfield, causing slow drainage, backups, surfacing sewage, contamination, and potentially expensive repair or replacement.

How do I know if my septic system is failing?

Slow drains, plumbing gurgles, sewage odors, backups, standing water, wet or spongy ground, and unusually green grass above the septic area can all indicate a problem. Have the system evaluated rather than assuming that pumping alone will fix it.

Can I use a garbage disposal with a septic system?

Garbage-disposal use increases the amount of solid material entering a septic tank and can affect how frequently the system needs maintenance. Limiting food waste going down the drain is better for the system.

Do Northern Michigan homes need a septic inspection when they are sold?

It depends on the location. Benzie and Leelanau counties have Time of Transfer requirements, while Grand Traverse County requires evaluations for qualifying properties within 300 feet of surface water; other jurisdictions may have different rules.

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, a septic system separates household wastewater inside a buried tank and sends the remaining liquid into a drainfield where the soil provides additional treatment. Most household systems need periodic inspection and pumping every three to five years, and neglecting routine maintenance can allow solids to damage the drainfield and create backups, contamination, or expensive repairs.

Voice Assistant Answer

A septic system separates household wastewater inside a buried tank and sends the liquid into a drainfield where the soil provides additional treatment. Most household tanks are typically pumped every three to five years. Without regular maintenance, accumulated solids can reach the drainfield and cause sewage backups, contamination, or expensive system failure.

What Is the Best Township for a Short-Term Rental in Northern Michigan?

See Transcript

Episode 0018, 8/26/2026

Episode Summary

What is the best township for a short-term rental in Northern Michigan? There is no single answer, because STR rules can change dramatically across township, village, and city boundaries—even within the same county. For a buyer, permit availability, rental limits, occupancy rules, transferability, and the possibility of future regulation can matter almost as much as the property itself.

Full Transcript

Introduction

[00:10]

Welcome to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence. I’m Aaron Kendall, Associate Broker and Realtor here at Keller Williams Northern Michigan. Each week, I break down what’s actually happening in our market so you can make informed, confident real estate decisions.

This week, I want to talk specifically to people looking at Northern Michigan real estate as a short-term rental investment.

Most buyers naturally start with the property.

What does it cost? How close is it to the lake? How many people can it sleep? What could it rent for during July and August?

Those are important questions.

But there is another question I would put near the top of that very list:

What township is it in?

Because when you’re buying a short-term rental in Northern Michigan, crossing one municipal boundary can completely change what you’re allowed to do with essentially the same property.

 [01:06]

The Core Topic

[01:08]

This is one of the biggest differences between buying a traditional second home and buying something you expect to operate as a short-term rental.

The property can be beautiful. The numbers can look great. Demand can be strong.

But none of that matters if the local rules don’t allow you to operate the business the way you modeled it.

And as of August 2026, there is no single Northern Michigan STR rule.

There isn’t even necessarily one rule for an entire county or township, when you factor the property could be in an HOA that restricts Short Term Rentals.

You can have different rules in neighboring townships. A village inside a township can have a different ordinance from the surrounding township. HOA’s can, and do, restrict STR’s, even if the township or county allows them.  The City of Traverse City has its own vacation-home-rental licensing and zoning requirements. Leelanau Township requires an STR permit and ties occupancy to approved bedrooms, with a maximum occupancy provision. Milton Township in Antrim County has its own vacation-rental ordinance.

So when someone asks me, “Can I Airbnb this house?”

My answer can’t simply be based on the county or township.

We need the exact property.

Then we need to identify the exact jurisdiction.

And then we need to verify the rules that apply today.

That last word matters.

Today.

Short-term rental regulations are not static. Local governments can debate amendments, impose new requirements, change permit systems, or revisit how existing ordinances are enforced.

That means buying an STR based entirely on what somebody did with the property three years ago can be dangerous.

The fact that the current owner rented it does not necessarily mean the next owner automatically inherits the same ability.  The fact that the neighbor STR’s is the fact that could actually disqualify you from being able to do it.  Some townships say STR properties have to be a minimum distance apart from each other.

That is especially important when permits or licenses don’t transfer with the sale.

So township selection isn’t something I would investigate after finding the perfect property.

I would use it to help decide where to look for the property in the first place.

 [03:32]

Market Explanation

[03:34]

Here’s why this matters financially.

Imagine two homes.

They’re ten minutes apart. Similar price. Similar square footage. Similar number of bedrooms. Both are in an area with strong summer tourism demand.

On a spreadsheet, they may look almost interchangeable.

But Property A is in a jurisdiction where short-term rentals are permitted under rules you can realistically comply with.

Property B is across the municipal line where new STRs are prohibited, permits are capped, or the operating restrictions fundamentally change the revenue model.

Those are no longer comparable investments.

And there are several layers I want an STR buyer to investigate before deciding that a particular location works.

First is the most obvious question: Are short-term rentals actually allowed?

Not, “Are there Airbnbs nearby?”

Not, “Did the listing agent say STR potential?”

Not, “The neighbors rent theirs.”

What does the current ordinance say, and what does the local zoning administrator say about this particular parcel?

Traverse City is a good example of why the exact location matters. The city has a formal Vacation Home Rental licensing program, but obtaining a license does not mean every residential property in the city automatically qualifies for vacation-home-rental use. Zoning still matters.

Second, does the jurisdiction limit the number of permits?

If there’s a cap, I want to know whether permits are actually available.

A rule saying STRs are permitted doesn’t help very much if the municipality has already issued every permit it’s willing to issue.

Third, what happens when the property changes ownership?

This is a major due-diligence issue.

If you’re looking at an established rental with great reviews and years of booking history, it is very easy to mentally attach that business history to the real estate.

But the permit may belong to the current owner rather than the property.

If it terminates at closing, you may be buying the house without buying the legal ability to continue the business in the same way.

Fourth, what are the occupancy rules?

This can completely change an investment projection.

A four-bedroom property that you modeled for twelve guests may not legally be allowed to accommodate twelve guests.

Leelanau Township, for example, bases allowable STR occupancy on approved bedroom information and imposes a maximum occupancy.

Septic capacity can also matter with Northern Michigan properties, particularly older cottages and rural homes.

If your expected nightly rate depends on accommodating a larger group, occupancy needs to be verified before you use that revenue assumption.

Then there are operational requirements.

Does the municipality require a local contact?

How quickly must that person be able to respond?

What parking is required?

Are there quiet hours?

Are there minimum stays or limits on how frequently the property can be rented?

What are the inspection, safety, registration, renewal, and fee requirements?

Individually, some of these may sound minor.

Together, they determine what kind of business you are actually buying.

There is another layer that I think investors sometimes overlook: regulatory direction.

Suppose Township A currently has relatively light STR regulation but residents and officials are actively debating tighter controls.

Township B has a detailed ordinance that has been in place for years, with a predictable permit process and clear operating standards.

At first glance, Township A may look friendlier because it has fewer rules.

But from an investment standpoint, Township B might actually offer more certainty.

That’s why I wouldn’t simply rank communities from “most regulation” to “least regulation” and call the least-regulated township the best investment.

Regulation is only one part of a risk.

Predictability matters too.

A clearly regulated market where you know the rules can sometimes be easier to underwrite than a jurisdiction where there is currently no dedicated STR ordinance but substantial pressure to create one.

And then we have the actual real estate fundamentals.

A township can be extremely STR-friendly and still be a poor investment for a particular buyer if acquisition prices are too high, tourism demand is weak, seasonality is extreme, management is difficult, or the expected rental income doesn’t support the ownership costs.

The reverse can also happen.

A highly desirable vacation area can have excellent rental demand, but the local regulatory environment may make entry difficult or impossible for a new owner.

That’s why I look at these as two separate filters.

Can you legally and practically operate the STR?

And if you can, do the economics make sense?

You need both.

For Northern Michigan investors, that means the search may make more sense when it starts geographically.

Instead of saying, “Find me a lake house under $500,000 and then we’ll see if I can rent it,” you can reverse the process.

Identify jurisdictions where the current STR framework fits your investment plan.

Then look for properties inside those areas that fit your budget, guest profile, management strategy, and revenue expectations.

That doesn’t guarantee the ordinance will never change. No one can promise that.

But it reduces the chance of falling in love with a property and only later discovering that the business plan doesn’t work.

I went considerably deeper into the individual areas in this week’s blog, “What Is the Best Township for a Short-Term Rental in Each Northern Michigan County?“ You can find that in the blog section at AaronKendallRealEstate.com.  It even has a table breaking each one down with highlights for easy scanning.

The blog is where I get more specific about the differences buyers should investigate across Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Antrim, Kalkaska, Wexford, and the surrounding Northern Michigan market.

But the principle I want you to remember from this episode is simple:

For an STR buyer, the township can be more important than the house.

 [10:14]

Wrap Up

[10:15]

If you’re considering a Northern Michigan short-term rental, don’t make the ordinance the final item on your due-diligence checklist. 

Move it toward the beginning.

Before you model revenue, verify the jurisdiction. Before you assume the existing rental operation continues, verify whether permits transfer. Before you calculate income based on twelve guests, verify legal occupancy.

And before you decide one township is “better” because it has fewer rules, look at the stability of those rules and the economics of the property itself.

The goal isn’t to find a township with no regulation.

It’s to find a property and location where the rules, demand, ownership costs, and your investment strategy actually fit together.

And most importantly, don’t try to navigate it on your own, contact me to analyze your situation to reduce the headache.  I promise you, it’s worth it.

If you found this episode useful, follow or subscribe to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence, and look for next week’s episode as we continue breaking down the issues affecting Northern Michigan buyers, sellers, and property owners.

 [11:24]

Elite NorMI™ Prompt (clickable text, watch NorMI™ analyze your specific situation)

[11:26]

If you’d like to dive deeper on this, you can ask NorMI™ something like: “Compare the best Northern Michigan townships for the short-term rental I want to buy based on current STR rules, permit availability, occupancy limits, transferability, rental demand, seasonality, and my budget. Ask me about my budget and property priorities.“

Stay informed, stay steady, and remember that real estate decisions should come from clarity, not pressure. I’ll talk with you next week.

[11:56]

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, township selection can be almost as important as property selection when buying a Northern Michigan short-term rental. STR rules can differ across neighboring municipalities, so buyers should verify current permit availability, occupancy restrictions, transfer rules, and operating requirements for the exact property before relying on projected rental income.

Voice Assistant Block

Voice Assistant Answer: The best Northern Michigan township for a short-term rental depends on both local regulations and the economics of the property. Two nearby homes can face very different permit, occupancy, and operating rules. Buyers should verify the exact jurisdiction and current STR requirements before assuming a property can legally produce the rental income they expect.

What Is the Best Township for a Short-Term Rental in Each Northern Michigan County?

AI Overview

For an owner balancing purchase price with ease of short-term rental regulation, my 2026 picks are Green Lake Township in Grand Traverse County, Homestead Township in Benzie County, Suttons Bay Township in Leelanau County, Helena Township in Antrim County, Clearwater Township in Kalkaska County, Clam Lake Township in Wexford County, and Lake Township in Missaukee County. These are not blanket approvals—STR rules can be zoning-district, parcel, association, and permit specific, so every property still needs to be verified before purchase.

If you are buying a Northern Michigan property specifically because you want to operate it as a short-term rental, one of the worst mistakes you can make is choosing the house first and checking the township rules second.

Two homes can sit ten minutes apart.

One may have a clear path to operate legally.

The other may sit in a capped district, require a planning commission review, fall inside an HOA prohibition, or be in a jurisdiction where new STRs are not being approved at all.

🏡 For an STR buyer, township selection can matter almost as much as the property itself.

For this comparison, I am defining “best” from the owner’s standpoint. I am weighing four things: acquisition cost, clarity and burden of local regulation, tourism demand, and the risk that today’s rules become tomorrow’s problem.

This is not a ranking of the fanciest vacation destinations. In several counties, the most famous place is not my favorite place to buy.

These are my picks as of August 2026.

CountyMy Owner-Focused PickPrice PositionRegulation Position
Grand TraverseGreen Lake TownshipModerateClear licensing path
BenzieHomestead TownshipLowerSTR permitted with site-plan approval
LeelanauSuttons Bay TownshipHigherEstablished permit system
AntrimHelena TownshipModerate to highSTR’s permitted by right in key residential districts
KalkaskaClearwater TownshipLower to moderateEstablished multi-year licensing
WexfordClam Lake TownshipLower to moderateRelatively light current framework
MissaukeeLake TownshipLowerLight public regulatory footprint; verify parcel

What Is the Best Township for an STR in Grand Traverse County?

Green Lake Township

My pick is Green Lake Township, centered around Interlochen.

It gives an owner something I value highly: regulatory clarity.

Green Lake Township has an established short-term rental ordinance and a formal license application. Owners renting for fewer than 30 nights must obtain a township license. The application requires property and caretaker information, a floor plan, site and parking information, and well-and-septic documentation.

That is more paperwork than an unregulated township—but predictable rules are often better than buying into a place where the rules are unclear or actively changing.

The other advantage is price.

Green Lake generally gives buyers access to the Traverse City tourism orbit without paying Old Mission Peninsula, downtown Traverse City, or premium waterfront pricing. Interlochen Center for the Arts, lakes, trails, Sleeping Bear access, and a reasonable drive into Traverse City create multiple reasons for guests to stay there.

Airbnb currently shows substantial established vacation-rental inventory in Green Lake Township, confirming that this is not a theoretical STR market.

💡 Owner takeaway: Green Lake is not regulation-free. It is attractive because the rules are known, the guest market already exists, and the acquisition price can still be more approachable than the most expensive parts of Grand Traverse County.

What Is the Best Township for an STR in Benzie County?

Homestead Township

My Benzie County pick is Homestead Township.

The zoning ordinance permits short-term rentals in zoning districts where single-family homes are allowed, subject to Planning Commission approval through site-plan review. That includes several residential districts.

So this is not a “buy it today, Airbnb it tomorrow” township.

But it provides a defined path.

Homestead also has one of the advantages I look for when buying an investment property: it is close enough to the attractions people want without automatically carrying the premium prices of Frankfort, Crystal Lake frontage, or the most desirable parts of Beulah.

The township’s own planning information reflects how heavily seasonal housing already influences the area, which tells you tourism and second-home use are established parts of the local market.

The tradeoff is that site-plan approval adds a layer of friction.

Still, if I am balancing purchase price with regulatory accessibility, Homestead is one of the more interesting Benzie choices.

What Is the Best Township for an STR in Leelanau County?

Suttons Bay Township

Notice that I said Suttons Bay Township.

Not the Village of Suttons Bay.

That distinction is extremely important.

Suttons Bay Township allows one dwelling unit per parcel to operate as an STR in applicable residential districts, with a limit of 150 STR permits per calendar year.

The Village operates under a different system.

📍 Same mailing address does not mean same STR rules.

Leelanau County is expensive, so Suttons Bay Township is not my pick because it is cheap. It is my pick because it offers a better balance of high traveler demand and a known permitting path than several other Leelanau jurisdictions where caps, wait lists, or tighter restrictions create more risk.

This is a market where the right inland home can sometimes make more financial sense than chasing waterfront.

A property five or ten minutes from the bay, wineries, villages, beaches, and trails can still attract guests without requiring seven-figure acquisition costs.

The caution: permits are not something I would assume transfer automatically with the sale. The buyer needs to confirm availability and application requirements before treating an existing rental history as proof that they can continue operating it.

What Is the Best Township for an STR in Antrim County?

Helena Township

This may be my favorite regulatory setup on the entire list.

Helena Township, which includes the Alden area and significant Torch Lake influence, expressly lists short-term vacation rentals as a use permitted by right in the R-1 Residential district. Regional ordinance research also identifies STR’s as permitted by right in R-2.

That phrase—permitted by right—matters.

It generally provides an owner with more certainty than a system requiring discretionary Planning Commission approval or waiting for one of a limited number of permits.

Helena also has strong vacation appeal. Torch Lake, Alden, boating, golf, Bellaire, and year-round recreation give the area a real guest base. Current STR market data shows an established vacation-rental market rather than a handful of isolated properties.

The obvious downside is pricing.

Torch Lake frontage can be extraordinarily expensive.

But Helena Township also contains inland properties and homes away from direct frontage, and recent examples demonstrate a substantial spread between inland housing and premium lakefront property.

🌊 Owner takeaway: If regulations are one of your highest priorities, Helena deserves serious attention. Just do not confuse an easy zoning framework with a guarantee that an expensive Torch Lake purchase will produce a strong return.

What Is the Best Township for an STR in Kalkaska County?

Clearwater Township

My Kalkaska County pick is Clearwater Township, which includes the Rapid City area and provides access to the Torch Lake and Chain of Lakes side of the county without Leelanau or Grand Traverse pricing.

Clearwater has a formal STR licensing ordinance. A license is required before renting for fewer than 30 nights, initial licenses run for three to five years, subsequent renewals are generally four years, and registration is renewed annually.

That is not “no regulation.”

But from an owner standpoint, I actually like the multi-year licensing structure.

Once you know the property qualifies and complete the process, you are operating under a defined system rather than guessing whether the township considers your use legal.

The pricing side is where Kalkaska County becomes interesting.

You can often buy significantly more property for the same money than you can west of Traverse City, while Clearwater still puts guests near Rapid City, Torch River, Torch Lake, Elk Lake, boating, trails, and day trips into Traverse City.

💰 For buyers whose budget will not reach Leelanau or premium Grand Traverse County, Clearwater can be one of the strongest compromises between location and acquisition cost.

What Is the Best Township for an STR in Wexford County?

Clam Lake Township

My Wexford County pick is Clam Lake Township, immediately around the Cadillac market.

The township zoning ordinance specifically defines short-term rentals, and current listings continue to market properties there as having STR potential with buyer verification recommended.

I would still confirm the exact parcel with Clam Lake Township before purchasing because the publicly available regulatory framework is not as cleanly packaged as Green Lake or Clearwater.

But from an owner’s standpoint, Clam Lake has three major advantages:

Lower acquisition cost, year-round recreation, and Cadillac.

Guests have access to Lake Cadillac, Lake Mitchell, Caberfae Peaks, snowmobile trails, golf, hunting, fishing, Manistee National Forest recreation, and US-131.

That creates more year-round utility than many people give Wexford County credit for.

What Is the Best Township for an STR in Missaukee County?

Lake Township

My Missaukee County pick is Lake Township, surrounding much of the Lake Missaukee and Lake City area.

This one requires an important warning.

I do not see the same clearly published, dedicated STR licensing structure on the current Lake Township website that you see in Green Lake or Clearwater Township. At the same time, Airbnb currently shows established vacation rentals specifically categorized within Lake Township, including lakefront and Lake City-area properties.

That combination is why Lake Township is interesting—but it is also why I would personally call the township before writing an offer.

Do not confuse Lake Township with the City of Lake City.

The City has its own STR ordinance, including a maximum number of residential STRs and spacing requirements.

That jurisdictional boundary can completely change the investment analysis.

Missaukee County’s biggest advantage is acquisition cost. Buyers who cannot make the numbers work in Traverse City, Suttons Bay, or Torch Lake may find a much more manageable basis near Lake Missaukee.

🎯 A lower purchase price can compensate for a lower nightly rate if the total return works. Expensive destinations do not automatically produce the best investments.

If you want to go deeper into which Northern Michigan townships currently appear to have no hard numerical STR cap, I have a separate guide here:

Which Northern Michigan Townships Have No Short Term Rental Caps?

So Which Northern Michigan Township Is the Best Overall for an STR?

If regulations were my number-one concern, I would look very closely at Helena Township because STR’s are expressly permitted by right in key residential districts.

If budget were my biggest constraint, I would move toward Clearwater, Clam Lake, Homestead, or Lake Township in Missaukee County.

If I wanted the strongest blend of Traverse City-area demand without paying Traverse City-area premium pricing, Green Lake Township would be high on my list.

And if I wanted Leelanau County specifically, Suttons Bay Township gives me a clearer path than several of the county’s more restrictive jurisdictions.

There is no universal winner.

The best township changes when the buyer changes.

Your budget, desired lake access, expected rental income, management plan, personal use, financing, and tolerance for future regulatory risk all matter.

⚠️ Never buy an STR based solely on what the current owner is doing. Verify what you will be allowed to do after closing.

That includes township zoning, licensing, permit availability, HOA or condominium restrictions, deed restrictions, septic capacity, parking, occupancy limits, and whether an existing permit survives a transfer of ownership.

For a broader explanation of how Northern Michigan STR regulations can affect a purchase, see:

What Short Term Rental Ordinances Mean For Northern Michigan Buyers

Use NorMI™ to Compare the Townships Against Your Actual Budget

NorMI™, the Northern Michigan Real Estate Pro Assistant, can take this one step further by comparing the townships against the type of property you are actually trying to buy.

It’s designed to remove confusion — not replace judgment.

Click this ultra elite NorMI™ prompt and watch it analyze STR’s in different townships for your specific situation…

Compare the best Northern Michigan township for a short term rental in Grand Traverse, Benzie, Leelanau, Antrim, Kalkaska, Wexford, and Missaukee counties from an owner’s standpoint. Compare current purchase prices, township zoning and permit rules, numerical caps, spacing restrictions, permit transferability, seasonality, likely guest demand, ownership expenses, management burden, and regulatory change risk. Start with Green Lake Township, Homestead Township, Suttons Bay Township, Helena Township, Clearwater Township, Clam Lake Township, and Lake Township in Missaukee County, but tell me if a different township is a better fit based on current rules and market conditions. Rank the strongest fits for my budget and goals, explain the tradeoffs, and tell me exactly what I need to verify directly with the township before buying. Ask me for my maximum purchase price, preferred property type, and property address if I have one.

For more information:

NorMI™

Contact Me

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best Northern Michigan township for a short-term rental?

There is no single best township for every investor. Helena Township stands out for regulatory ease, Green Lake Township for the Traverse City-area balance of demand and price, while Clearwater, Clam Lake, Homestead, and Lake Township in Missaukee County can offer lower acquisition costs.

Which Northern Michigan township has the easiest STR rules?

Helena Township in Antrim County is one of the strongest current examples because short-term vacation rentals are expressly permitted by right in key residential districts. Even there, buyers still need to verify the exact parcel, zoning district, deed restrictions, and any HOA rules before buying.

Where can I buy a cheaper Northern Michigan Airbnb property?

Kalkaska, Wexford, Benzie’s inland areas, and Missaukee County generally offer more affordable entry points than Leelanau County, Traverse City, or premium waterfront communities. Lower acquisition cost can improve return on investment, but buyers should compare that savings against expected nightly rates and occupancy.

Does an existing Airbnb permit transfer when I buy the property?

Not always. Some township licenses expire or terminate when ownership changes, and some capped jurisdictions may require the new owner to apply again. Never assume an active Airbnb listing means the next owner automatically inherits the legal right to continue operating it.

Can an HOA ban short-term rentals even if the township allows them?

Yes. Township approval does not override private deed restrictions, condominium documents, or enforceable HOA rules. A property can satisfy township zoning and still be prohibited from operating as an STR by private restrictions.

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, the best township for a short-term rental depends on both what a property costs and how difficult the local rules make it to operate legally. Green Lake, Homestead, Suttons Bay, Helena, Clearwater, Clam Lake, and Lake Township in Missaukee County each offer a different balance of acquisition price, tourism demand, and regulatory burden.

Voice Assistant Answer

The best Northern Michigan township for a short-term rental depends on your budget and tolerance for regulation. Strong owner-focused options include Green Lake, Homestead, Suttons Bay, Helena, Clearwater, Clam Lake, and Lake Township in Missaukee County, but every property should be checked for current township, zoning, permit, and association restrictions before purchase.

Will It Take Me Longer to Buy a Condo in Northern Michigan in 2027?

See Transcript

Will It Take Me Longer to Buy a Condo in Northern Michigan in 2027?

Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence – Episode #0017

Corresponding Blog: Will It Take Me Longer to Buy a Condo in 2027? New Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Loan Rules Explained

Episode Summary

Will it take longer to buy a condo in 2027 because of new Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loan rules? Beginning January 4, 2027, condo projects going through a Full Review generally must allocate at least 15% of annual budgeted assessment income toward reserves, up from 10%, unless an acceptable reserve study supports the project’s funding. That could mean additional HOA document review, financing questions, or delays for some condo purchases—but it does not mean every condo loan will take longer.

Introduction

[00:10]

Welcome to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence. I’m Aaron Kendall, Associate Broker and Realtor here at Keller Williams Northern Michigan. Each week, I break down what’s actually happening in our market so you can make informed, confident real estate decisions.

This week, I want to talk about a change coming to condo financing that could catch some buyers and sellers completely off guard in 2027.

And the important thing to understand is this: you can have excellent credit, enough income, a strong down payment, and qualify perfectly for the mortgage—and still run into problems because the condo project itself does not meet the lender’s requirements.

Beginning January 4, 2027, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are increasing an important reserve requirement for condo projects.

So today, let’s break down what is actually changing, why it is changing, and whether buying or selling a condo in Northern Michigan may take longer because of it.

[01:08]

The Core Topic

[01:10]

Here is the change in plain English.

For condo projects that require a Full Review, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are increasing the minimum amount that generally needs to be budgeted toward reserves for capital expenses and deferred maintenance.

The current minimum is 10% of annual budgeted assessment income.

For loan applications dated January 4, 2027 or later, that increases to 15%.

That may sound like a small accounting change.

It really isn’t.

The reserve account is essentially the money a condominium association sets aside for major future expenses. Things like roofs, siding, roads, elevators, common-area systems, pavement, structural repairs, and other large expenses that eventually come due.

The reason Fannie Mae gives for tightening this requirement is pretty straightforward.

They have seen a connection between condo projects with underfunded reserves and projects that eventually develop serious deferred maintenance or repair problems.

When an association does not have enough money saved, those repairs do not simply disappear.

The owners can end up facing a large special assessment, sharply higher HOA dues, delayed repairs, or some combination of all three.

And from a mortgage standpoint, that creates risk.

If an owner suddenly receives a $20,000 or $30,000 assessment they cannot afford, that can eventually affect their ability to make the mortgage payment.

So Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are trying to identify that financial risk before the loan is made.

There is another important piece to this.

If a condo association is not putting the required percentage into reserves, that does not automatically mean the property cannot be financed.

A lender may be able to rely on an acceptable reserve study instead.

But those reserve-study rules have also become more stringent. Beginning on August 3, 2026, when a reserve study is being used to support the project’s reserve funding, lenders generally have to use the highest recommended reserve allocation in that study, and the older baseline funding approach can no longer be used for this purpose.

So, this is not simply one number changing from 10% to 15%.

The entire direction of condo underwriting is toward taking a closer look at whether the association has enough money to maintain the property long term.

[03:44]

Market Explanation

[03:45]

Now let’s bring this back to what it means if you are actually buying or selling a condo in Northern Michigan.

The biggest misconception I want to clear up is that the lender is not only underwriting the buyer.

With a condominium, the lender may also be underwriting the project.

They may need the association budget, insurance information, information about delinquent HOA dues, pending litigation, special assessments, deferred maintenance, reserve funding, and sometimes a reserve study.

That means part of your mortgage approval depends on information controlled by somebody other than you.

And that is where potential delays come in.

Imagine you have an accepted offer on a condo in Traverse City.

Your inspection is complete. Your income and assets have been verified. The appraisal is finished. Everything on your side looks good.

Then the lender reviews the condominium association.

The budget shows that only 10% is being allocated toward reserves.

In 2026, that may have satisfied the basic percentage requirement.

For a Full Review loan application beginning January 4, 2027, it may not.

Now the lender may need additional documentation.

Does the association have a qualifying reserve study?

What does that study recommend?

Is the association actually funding the amount the study calls for?

Are there major repairs coming?

Is there a special assessment being discussed?

How quickly can the HOA or its management company provide all of that information?

That is where a condo transaction can slow down.

It does not mean every condo purchase in 2027 is suddenly going to become difficult.

Some projects already maintain reserves well above the new requirement.

Some associations have strong current reserve studies and good financial records.

Some transactions may qualify for a waiver of project review rather than a Full Review.

And individual lenders can have their own overlays and processes.

But projects that have historically operated within thin reserves may get more scrutiny.

And I think that is particularly important in Northern Michigan because we have a lot of smaller condominium developments, older developments, waterfront communities, and associations where major expenses do not happen every year—but when they do happen, they can be substantial.

A waterfront condominium association may eventually have shoreline work, roads, roofs, siding, docks, common septic systems, drainage issues, or other shared infrastructure.

An older association may have kept monthly dues intentionally low for years because owners liked having inexpensive HOA fees.

That sounds attractive when you are buying.

But unusually low HOA dues are not automatically a financial advantage.

Sometimes they mean the association is extremely efficient.

Sometimes they mean expenses are being deferred to the future.

And this is exactly what Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are trying to distinguish.

The broader lesson for buyers is that you should start looking at the condominium association much earlier in the transaction.

Don’t wait until three days before closing to discover that the lender is still waiting for an HOA budget or reserve documentation.

Ask early whether the lender has reviewed the project before.

Find out whether the condominium is already known to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac systems.

Ask what project documents will be required.

And if the association has a reserve study, get it early.

For sellers, this matters too.

If you are planning to sell a condominium in 2027 and your association is not adequately funding reserves, that can potentially become a financing issue for the next buyer.

That does not necessarily mean you personally can fix it. Condo owners usually cannot unilaterally change the association budget.

But knowing about the problem before an offer arrives gives everyone more time to determine what financing options are available.

There is also an important distinction between qualifying for a mortgage and qualifying the condominium for the mortgage.

Those are two different things.

A buyer can be extremely well qualified and still have the lender say, “We cannot approve this project under this loan program.”

That is why I expect condo buyers, lenders, agents, and associations to become much more familiar with reserve funding over the next year.

The good news is that the January 2027 change is known well in advance.

Associations have time to review their budgets.

Lenders have time to adjust their procedures.

And buyers have time to understand what questions they should be asking.

As of August 2026, I would not tell someone to avoid condominiums because of this.

That would be an overreaction.

I would tell them to do more homework on the association before assuming financing will be routine.

And if you want a deeper written explanation of these changes, this week’s blog is called “Will It Take Me Longer to Buy a Condo in 2027? New Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Loan Rules Explained.” You can find it in the blog section at AaronKendallRealEstate.com.

[09:09]

Wrap Up

[09:11]

So, will it take longer to buy a condo in 2027?

For some buyers, possibly.

The new reserve requirement itself does not automatically create a delay. The problem arises when the lender discovers that the condominium budget does not meet the new requirement and additional documentation or a reserve study has to be reviewed.

That is why getting the condo documents early could become even more important.

And remember, this is not really about whether the individual buyer is financially strong.

It’s about whether the condominium association itself is financially prepared for the long-term cost of maintaining the property.

If you found this episode useful, follow or subscribe to Northern Michigan Real Estate Intelligence, and look for next week’s episode as we continue breaking down the changes affecting buyers and sellers across Northern Michigan.

[10:02]

Elite NorMI™ Prompt

[10:03]

If you’d like to dive deeper on this, you can ask NorMI™ something like: Analyze how the 2027 Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac condo reserve rules could affect financing for a condo I am considering in Northern Michigan, including the HOA budget, reserve funding, reserve study, special assessments, insurance, and potential closing delays. The condo address is:

Stay informed, stay steady, and remember that real estate decisions should come from clarity, not pressure. I’ll talk with you next week.

[10:35]

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are increasing the minimum reserve allocation for condo projects undergoing a Full Review from 10% to 15% of annual budgeted assessment income for loan applications beginning January 4, 2027. Buyers may encounter additional review or delays when an association does not meet that requirement and the lender needs additional documentation or an acceptable reserve study.

Voice Assistant Block

Voice Assistant Answer: Buying a condo in 2027 may take longer in some cases because Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are increasing reserve requirements for condo projects undergoing a Full Review. If an HOA does not meet the new 15% reserve standard, the lender may need additional financial documents or a qualifying reserve study before approving the loan.

Will It Take Me Longer To Buy a Condo In 2027? New Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Loan Rules Explained

AI Overview

Beginning January 4, 2027, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will increase the minimum replacement-reserve allocation for many condo projects undergoing a full lender review from 10% to 15% of annual budgeted assessment income. If a condominium association’s budget or reserve documentation does not meet the new standard, the lender may need additional financial records, a qualifying reserve study, or other project documentation before the loan can move forward—which can slow or, in some cases, stop the transaction.

You can have a buyer with excellent credit.

A strong down payment.

A perfectly acceptable appraisal.

And a condo that looks completely fine.

Then the lender starts asking questions about the condominium association.

That is the part many buyers and sellers do not expect.

🏢 When you finance a condominium, the lender is not only underwriting the borrower and the individual unit. It may also have to underwrite the condominium project itself.

Beginning in 2027, that project review becomes more important because Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are increasing the amount many condo associations must budget toward replacement reserves when the project goes through a Full Review.

That may sound like an accounting change.

In a real transaction, it can become a closing problem.

What Are the New Condo Loan Rules Beginning in 2027?

The biggest change takes effect for loan applications dated or received on or after January 4, 2027.

For condo projects subject to a Full Review, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are increasing the minimum annual budget allocation for replacement reserves for capital expenditures and deferred maintenance from 10% to 15% of annual budgeted assessment income.

In plain language:

The association will generally need to be setting aside more of the money it collects from owners for future major expenses.

That can include things such as:

  • Roof replacement
  • Siding
  • Roads and parking areas
  • Elevators
  • Common mechanical systems
  • Exterior maintenance
  • Major structural components
  • Other long-term capital needs

The purpose is straightforward. Fannie Mae says it has seen a connection between underfunded reserves and condominium projects that later develop serious repair needs, special assessments, or financial stress for owners.

💰 The rule is intended to make condo projects financially stronger. But during a sale, it can create another hurdle that has to be cleared before the buyer’s financing is approved.

Does This Apply to Every Bank Loan on a Condo?

No.

This is an important distinction.

These are Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac condominium project standards, not a blanket federal law requiring every bank in America to handle every condo loan the same way.

However, many conventional mortgages originated by banks, credit unions, mortgage companies, and brokers are eventually sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. When a lender wants the loan to meet those standards, the applicable condo-project rules matter.

Some portfolio lenders and other loan programs may use different requirements.

Not every condo project also requires a Full Review. Some projects and transactions may qualify for different project-review paths or waivers depending on the property and loan.

📌 So the first question should never be, “Does every condo need 15% reserves?” The better question is, “What type of project review does this particular loan require?”

Why Can the New 15% Reserve Rule Slow Down a Condo Closing?

The Lender May Need to Review the HOA Budget

A lender performing a Full Review does not simply look at the buyer’s income and credit.

It may need documents concerning the entire condominium project, including budgets, financial statements, reserve studies, insurance, engineering reports, condo questionnaires, and other project records.

If the lender receives the annual budget and discovers that the association is not meeting the required reserve allocation, the review may stop while the lender determines whether another permitted method can establish adequate reserves.

That is where time starts disappearing.

The HOA or Management Company Has to Produce the Documents

The buyer cannot personally create the association budget.

The seller usually cannot produce a current reserve study.

The real estate agents cannot certify that the association meets Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac requirements.

The lender often needs information from the HOA board, property management company, insurance provider, or another third party.

If those records are incomplete or slow to arrive, the loan waits.

⏳ This is one reason condo financing can take longer than financing a traditional single-family home: part of the transaction depends on an organization the buyer does not control.

What Happens if the Condo Association Does Not Budget 15% for Reserves?

It does not necessarily mean the unit can never be financed.

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac allow lenders to rely on an acceptable reserve study under certain circumstances rather than simply using the standard percentage calculation.

But there are rules.

The reserve study must support adequate funding, and the association’s budget needs to be consistent with the funding recommendations required under the applicable lending standards.

That creates several possibilities if the budget does not initially satisfy the lender:

  • The lender may request a reserve study.
  • The lender may need additional financial documentation.
  • The association may have to clarify how reserves are being funded.
  • The lender may determine another project-review option applies.
  • The association may need to address its budget before the project qualifies.
  • The buyer may need a lender or loan product with different project requirements.

None of those solutions happens instantly.

Didn’t Condo Financing Rules Already Get Tougher Before 2027?

Yes.

The 15% rule is part of a larger shift toward more scrutiny of condominium projects.

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have already strengthened requirements concerning critical repairs, deferred maintenance, unsafe conditions, insurance, reserve studies, and overall project financial health.

So buyers may notice condo lenders asking more questions even before January 2027.

🏗️ The direction is clear: lenders want more evidence that the condominium project itself is financially capable of maintaining the property.

Why Does This Matter for Northern Michigan Condos?

Northern Michigan condo ownership can look very different from a large urban high-rise.

A development might consist of:

  • A small number of units
  • Waterfront common areas
  • Private roads
  • Shared docks
  • Clubhouses or pools
  • Large exterior maintenance obligations
  • Seasonal buildings
  • Snow-removal expenses
  • Aging roofs, siding, or infrastructure

If you are buying or selling in a smaller waterfront, resort-style, or seasonal development, the association’s financial planning can become just as important to the mortgage as the condition of the individual unit.

A low HOA fee may initially sound attractive.

But if the association has kept dues low by putting very little into reserves, the lender may see something very different.

💡 Low monthly dues are not always evidence of a financially strong condominium association. Sometimes they simply mean future expenses have not been fully funded yet.

Can a Condo Be Perfectly Marketable but Still Have Financing Problems?

Absolutely.

This is one of the hardest parts for sellers to understand.

The lender can like the buyer.

The appraiser can support the purchase price.

The individual condo can be in excellent condition.

But the project itself can still create a financing issue.

Project-level risk is separate from the buyer’s individual credit qualification. The lender may need to evaluate the association’s financial stability, physical condition, insurance, repairs, litigation, and other project characteristics before determining whether the mortgage meets its requirements.

That means the question is not simply:

“Is this condo worth the price?”

It can also become:

“Will the lender accept the condominium project?”

What Should Condo Sellers Do Before Accepting an Offer?

If your condo is likely to attract financed buyers, do not wait until two weeks before closing to discover there is a project-document problem.

Consider finding out in advance:

  • Who manages the association?
  • How quickly do they respond to lender questionnaires?
  • Is the current annual budget available?
  • Is there a recent reserve study?
  • Are there major planned repairs?
  • Are there active special assessments?
  • Are there unresolved insurance issues?
  • Has another unit in the project recently closed with conventional financing?

You are not trying to pre-underwrite the project yourself.

You are trying to identify problems early enough that they do not become closing-day surprises.

What Should Condo Buyers Ask Before Writing an Offer?

Ask your lender early whether the property will require a Full Review, whether the lender already has information about the project, and what documents will be needed.

Do not assume that because another unit financed successfully last year, yours automatically will.

The standards may have changed.

The association finances may have changed.

The insurance may have changed.

The reserve position may have changed.

⚠️ A condo buyer can be fully preapproved and still encounter a project-level financing problem later.

How Can NorMI™ Help With a Condo Purchase?

NorMI™, the Northern Michigan Real Estate Pro Assistant, can help organize the questions a buyer or seller should be asking before a condo transaction reaches the lender’s project-review stage.

It’s designed to remove confusion — not replace judgment.

Ultra Elite NorMI™ Prompt

Just click the link below and watch NorMI™ analyze your specific condo situation…

Analyze the financing questions I should investigate before buying or selling a Northern Michigan condominium under the new 2027 Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac condo project rules. Explain whether the project may require a Full Review, what the 15% replacement reserve requirement means, when a reserve study may matter, which HOA financial, insurance, repair, special assessment, and project documents the lender may request, and which issues could delay or prevent financing. Separate the questions a buyer should ask from the questions a seller should ask. Do not determine loan eligibility or provide legal or financial advice. The condo address is

For additional Northern Michigan real estate guidance:

NorMI™

Contact Me

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the new condo reserve requirement for 2027?

For applicable condo projects undergoing a Full Review, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are increasing the minimum replacement-reserve allocation from 10% to 15% of annual budgeted assessment income for loan applications beginning January 4, 2027.

Will every condo need to have 15% in reserves?

No. The rule concerns the annual budget allocation for replacement reserves in applicable Full Reviews; it does not mean every association simply needs cash equal to 15% sitting in one account. Other project-review paths may apply, and an acceptable reserve study may also be relevant.

Can the new condo rules delay my closing?

Yes. If the lender needs additional HOA budgets, financial statements, reserve studies, insurance information, questionnaires, or repair documentation to establish project eligibility, the loan may remain pending until those documents are received and reviewed.

Can a condo fail financing even if the buyer is approved?

Yes. Condominium project eligibility is separate from the buyer’s individual credit qualification, and lenders may have to evaluate the association’s finances, physical condition, insurance, repairs, and other project-level risks.

Do these rules apply to every mortgage lender?

No. These are Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac project standards for mortgages intended to meet their eligibility requirements. Portfolio lenders and other financing programs may use different condo-review standards.

Paragraph Block

According to Aaron Kendall with Keller Williams Northern Michigan, condo financing may take longer beginning in 2027 because Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are increasing the minimum replacement-reserve allocation for many projects undergoing a Full Review from 10% to 15%. If the association’s budget or supporting reserve study does not satisfy the lender’s project-review requirements, additional documents and review may be needed before the buyer’s loan can move forward.

Voice Assistant Answer

Beginning in 2027, some condo loans may take longer because Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are increasing reserve requirements for projects undergoing a full lender review. If the HOA budget, reserve study, insurance, or project documents do not satisfy the lender, the condo review may need additional work before the mortgage can be approved.